White Tab 003▸ Entry — WT‑202 Discovery Packet (Julian Rivera — Total Restoration, Inc.)¶
GUARDRAIL: WHITE — FACT REPOSITORY ONLY
Facts & source pinpoints only. No strategy, no argument, no legal opinions. All quotations are "as reported" unless exact text appears in a cited source.
A) Objective & Custody (facts‑only)¶
Objective. Collect, authenticate, and Bates‑index the Total Restoration, Inc. (TRI) records for Julian Rivera tied to WT‑104 Meeting B.3 (Feb 26, 2020) — the post‑claim‑approval walkthrough/mold scope — and verify any presence at B.1 (Dec 11, 2019) or B.2 (mid/late Dec 2019). Targets include field artifacts, scope notes, communications, and materials exchanged with the public adjuster/carrier for G21 (226 Franklin St., Apt. G21 / entrance 97 Green St.).
Primary witness (White): Julian Rivera — Total Restoration, Inc. Role, dates, and reported statements are documented in WT‑202 witness profile.
Tenant non‑possession (explicit). TRI is an owner‑side contractor. The tenant does not possess TRI's job file, HR/personnel records, scope notes/estimates, internal communications, or originals of TRI photos; these reside with custodians (TRI; owner/owner's counsel; and, where shared, Power Adjustment and the carrier/IA).
Naming canon. Use Total Restoration, Inc. throughout (replace any legacy "Total Remediation/Industries" labels).
WT‑104 framework alignment (B.0–B.3):
- B.0 (late Nov 2019): No Rivera appearance recorded (Roussis baseline with Gray).
- B.1 (Dec 11, 2019): Rivera possible (TR representative = Roussis and/or Rivera — to be established).
- B.2 (mid/late Dec 2019): Rivera presence to be verified; Alex Morales not at B.2.
- B.3 (Feb 26, 2020): Rivera present (confirmed) — post‑claim‑approval walkthrough/mold scope.
Note: B.1 and B.2 occurred on different days.
B) Custodian Map (who holds what)¶
B.1 Total Restoration, Inc. (primary) — B.3 scope visit artifacts (scheduling, scope notes/estimate, photos, internal comms); TRI↔Owner/PA communications (Feb 2020); HR/personnel (title/authority for Rivera); W‑9/COI; entity print; safety/QA/retention policies.
B.2 American Package Co. / Owner's counsel (secondary) — TRI engagement chain; owner‑side transmittals to/from TRI; meeting scheduling for B.3; directives; payments to TRI.
B.3 Power Adjustment (secondary) — shared scopes/estimates with TRI; PA↔TRI comms (Katz↔Rivera); calendar invites for B.3; claim file entries referencing TRI.
B.4 Carrier / Independent Adjuster (secondary) — claim file; approval decision; payout ledger (date/amount/payee); any scope/valuation communications referencing TRI deliverables.
B.5 Regulators/Registries — NY DOS entity print for Total Restoration, Inc.; insurance broker/carrier (COI).
C) Granular Document Specifications (150+ items)¶
Enumerated specifications to request/collect from custodians. Built to WT‑302 standard.
C.1 Engagement & Authority (15)¶
1–15. Work authorization/contract for Feb 2020 scope visit; initial scope; job setup; site access; insurance requirements; subs; fee basis; change‑order procedures; closeout; suspension/termination (if any); contact sheet; internal routing/approval for B.3 attendance; supervisor chain for Rivera.
C.2 B.3 (Feb 26, 2020) Scope Visit Materials (25)¶
16–20. Calendar invite/scheduling for B.3; attendee confirmations; pre‑visit briefing notes.
21–25. Rivera scope notes/estimate from B.3 visit; room‑by‑room observations; mold remediation scope outline.
26–30. Photos taken at B.3 (originals with EXIF); photo index; device metadata.
31–35. Post‑B.3 follow‑up communications; revised scopes; action items.
36–40. Internal TRI approvals for scope/estimate; supervisor review notes; version history.
C.3 B.1/B.2 Presence Verification (15)¶
41–45. Calendar/scheduling artifacts for Dec 2019 meetings; attendee lists; TRI representation confirmation.
46–50. Any TRI materials prepared for or used at B.1/B.2; internal comms regarding these meetings.
51–55. Rivera‑specific attendance records or statements confirming presence/absence at B.1/B.2.
C.4 Communications — Email/Text/Calls (30)¶
56–60. TRI↔Owner comms (Jan–Mar 2020); scheduling; scope transmittals.
61–65. TRI↔Power Adjustment comms (Rivera↔Katz); calendar invites; meeting coordination.
66–70. TRI↔Carrier/IA comms (if any); scope submissions.
71–75. Internal TRI comms re G21 scope visit; supervisor chains; approval threads.
76–80. Text message exports (platform native with timestamps); call logs/notes.
81–85. Post‑B.3 follow‑ups; revised scope transmittals; action item tracking.
C.5 Photos & Media (15)¶
86–90. Original photos from B.3 visit (EXIF intact); video (if any).
91–95. Photo index (filename→location→timestamp); device make/model/SN.
96–100. Export logs; SHA‑256 manifest; storage path; backup confirmation.
C.6 HR / Authority / Training (15)¶
101–105. Employment file for Rivera; position description; hire date; supervisor chain.
106–110. Title/authority as of Feb 26, 2020; current employment status.
111–115. Training/certifications (IICRC/mold remediation); ethics/confidentiality acknowledgments.
C.7 Carrier Approval & Payout (15)¶
116–120. Carrier approval decision for Studios 1 & 2 property‑damage claim; date of approval.
121–125. Payout ledger (date/amount/payee/characterization); disbursement records.
126–130. Power Adjustment claim file entries (valuations; submissions; "numbers" referenced at B.3).
C.8 Entity / COI / Billing (10)¶
131–135. W‑9 for Total Restoration, Inc.; COI (GL/PL); NY DOS entity print.
136–140. Invoices; rate sheets; payment applications; closeout summary.
C.9 Policies & Retention (10)¶
141–145. TRI SOPs for mold remediation; QA procedures; document retention policy.
146–150. Ethics policies; conflict checks; safety plan archive.
D) Interrogatories (25)¶
Engagement & Role (5)
- Who engaged TRI for the Feb 26, 2020 scope visit; date/scope provided.
- Identify all TRI personnel involved in G21; describe Rivera's role and authority.
- Supervisor chain for Rivera as of Feb 2020.
- Any prior TRI involvement at G21 (B.1/B.2 presence).
- Conflicts or limitations of scope.
B.3 Scope Visit (7)
- Date/time of arrival and departure for B.3; who was present.
- Scope notes/estimate prepared; versions and recipients.
- Photos taken; devices used; EXIF preservation.
- Statements made by Rivera at B.3 (hallway/kitchen sequence).
- Statements made by Katz at B.3 (reprimand; "padded the numbers").
- Follow‑up actions after B.3; revised scopes.
- Any discussions of claim approval status or payout amounts.
Communications (5)
- All TRI↔Owner communications (Jan–Mar 2020).
- All TRI↔Power Adjustment communications (Rivera↔Katz).
- All TRI↔Carrier/IA communications.
- Internal TRI communications regarding G21.
- Text messages and call logs related to G21.
Carrier/Claim (5)
- Knowledge of carrier approval decision; source of information.
- Knowledge of payout amount or timing; source.
- Any documents received from Power Adjustment regarding claim status.
- Any instructions regarding what to say or not say about claim status.
- Post‑B.3 communications about the reprimand or "padded the numbers" statement.
HR & Identity (3)
- Employment dates and titles for Rivera (Feb 2020 and current).
- Training/certifications held as of Feb 2020.
- Current contact information for Rivera.
E) Deposition Coordination (logistics only)¶
Topics. Engagement chain; B.3 scope visit (arrival/departure; attendees; observations); hallway disclosure (carrier approval statement); Katz reprimand; kitchen "padded the numbers" statement; scope/estimate evolution; TRI↔PA communications; B.1/B.2 presence verification; HR authority.
Materials. B.3 scope notes; photo set with EXIF; TRI↔PA email chain; carrier approval record (if produced); payout ledger (if produced); employment verification.
Sequencing (logistics only). Depose Rivera after Roussis and Katz so B.3 materials and reported statements are available for reference. Estimated duration: 4–6 hours.
F) Discovery Protocols (formats; Bates; privilege; meet‑and‑confer)¶
F.1 ESI. Email (.eml/.msg, families preserved); photos (originals + EXIF + SHA‑256); texts (platform export + timestamps); spreadsheets (.xlsx); calendar (.ics for B.3).
F.2 Bates. Prefix G21‑TRI‑; single‑page PDFs (OCR); load files (.DAT/.OPT) with NativeLink.
F.3 Privilege. Doc‑by‑doc with categorical allowance for large families.
F.4 Meet‑and‑Confer. Within 14 days (scope/custodians/formats/privilege).
F.5 Search Terms (baseline). "G21", "97 Green", "226 Franklin", "Rivera", "Julian", "Total Restoration", "TRI", "B.3", "Feb 26", "mold", "scope", "estimate", "Power Adjustment", "Katz", "Kofman", "American Package", "approval", "padded".
F.6 PII Redaction. SSNs/full DOBs/bank masked; log retained.
G) Bates Plan & Pinpoint Tasks¶
G.1 Bates Production (prefix: G21‑TRI‑).
- 202‑BATES‑01: B.3 scope visit materials (scheduling/notes/estimate) → G21‑TRI‑100001+
- 202‑BATES‑02: B.3 photos/media (originals + EXIF) → G21‑TRI‑100300+
- 202‑BATES‑03: Communications (TRI↔Owner/PA/Carrier) → G21‑TRI‑100600+
- 202‑BATES‑04: Carrier approval/payout records → G21‑TRI‑101000+
- 202‑BATES‑05: HR/authority (Rivera employment) → G21‑TRI‑101300+
- 202‑BATES‑06: Entity/COI/billing → G21‑TRI‑101500+
- 202‑BATES‑07: B.1/B.2 presence verification materials → G21‑TRI‑101700+
G.2 Pinpoint Tasks (WT‑104/102/103).
- 202‑PIN‑01 — WT‑104 B.3 page ref (hallway disclosure — carrier approval statement).
- 202‑PIN‑02 — WT‑104 B.3 page ref (Katz reprimand of Rivera).
- 202‑PIN‑03 — WT‑104 B.3 page ref ("padded the numbers" — Rivera as witness).
- 202‑PIN‑04 — WT‑102 (2019‑12‑03 email) page refs (context).
- 202‑PIN‑05 — Carrier approval record page ref (once produced).
- 202‑PIN‑06 — Payout ledger page ref (once produced).
Aliases for Binder search: 202‑PIN‑WT104‑B3‑HALL (→01) • 202‑PIN‑WT104‑B3‑REP (→02) • 202‑PIN‑WT104‑B3‑PAD (→03).
H) Priority‑Tiered Routing Grid¶
| Priority | Task ID | Artifact / Action | Custodian | Owner | Due | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P1 (30d) | 202‑COL‑B3‑1 | B.3 scope visit materials (scheduling, notes, estimate, photos) | Total Restoration, Inc. | Legal | +30d | Open |
| P1 (30d) | 202‑COL‑STMT‑1 | Rivera formal statement (B.3 sequence: hallway → reprimand → kitchen) | Rivera/TRI | Legal | +30d | Open |
| P1 (30d) | 202‑COL‑COMMS‑1 | TRI↔PA comms (Rivera↔Katz; Jan–Mar 2020) | TRI/PA | Legal | +30d | Open |
| P1 (30d) | 202‑COL‑CARR‑1 | Carrier approval decision + payout ledger (date/amount/payee) | Carrier/PA | Legal | +30d | Open |
| P1 (30d) | 202‑PIN‑01 | WT‑104 B.3 page pin (hallway disclosure) | Internal | Analyst | +30d | Open |
| P1 (30d) | 202‑PIN‑02 | WT‑104 B.3 page pin (reprimand) | Internal | Analyst | +30d | Open |
| P1 (30d) | 202‑PIN‑03 | WT‑104 B.3 page pin ("padded the numbers") | Internal | Analyst | +30d | Open |
| P2 (60d) | 202‑COL‑HR‑1 | Employment/title confirmation (Rivera; Feb 2020 and current) | TRI HR | Paralegal | +60d | Open |
| P2 (60d) | 202‑COL‑B1B2‑1 | B.1/B.2 presence verification (scheduling; attendee lists) | TRI | Paralegal | +60d | Open |
| P2 (60d) | 202‑COL‑ID‑AXM‑1 | Alex Morales identification (B.3 only; not at B.2) | TBD | Paralegal | +60d | Open |
| P3 (90d) | 202‑PIN‑ALL | Insert all PDF page pins across cross‑refs | Internal | Analyst | +90d | Open |
I) Cross‑References (White tabs)¶
Primary: WT‑202 (witness profile); WT‑104 (B.0–B.3 framework); WT‑102 (Dec 03 email); WT‑103 (Dec 18 declination).
Related witnesses: WT‑201 (Evan Katz — B.3 counterpart; reprimand/"padded the numbers"); WT‑203 (Chris Roussis — B.0/B.2; TRI).
Corporate: WT‑301 (Total Restoration, Inc. corporate profile).
Tracker: WT‑003 (master tracker with cascade inserts).
J) Preservation & Service¶
Preservation. Issue litigation hold to Total Restoration, Inc. covering G21 job file, scope notes/estimates, communications (TRI↔Owner/PA/Carrier), photos, and HR/personnel records for Julian Rivera (2019–present).
Service. Serve TRI through registered agent/counsel; owner‑side copies through American Package Co. (Martin C. Kofman); carrier records through Western World (if applicable).
K) Phased Discovery Strategy (5 phases)¶
Phase 1 (Days 1–30). Serve RFPs to TRI/Owner/Carrier; collect B.3 scope materials, core communications, carrier approval/payout records; Rivera statement.
Phase 2 (Days 31–60). HR/employment verification; B.1/B.2 presence materials; supplemental communications; Alex Morales identification.
Phase 3 (Days 61–90). Depositions — Roussis → Rivera → Katz (B.3 sequence established).
Phase 4 (Days 91–120). Expert discovery (if designated — mold remediation practices).
Phase 5 (Day 121+). Trial prep (exhibit sets; witness outlines; Bates ranges).
L) Non‑Response Procedures (4‑stage escalation)¶
+7 days: Courteous follow‑up → +14: Formal meet‑and‑confer (by RFP #) → +21: Motion to compel package → +30+: Sanctions (fees/adverse inference), as appropriate.
M) Document Review Workflow (9 steps)¶
Receipt log → Forensic copy & SHA‑256 manifest → Privilege review → Relevance coding → Bates stamping → Load file creation → QC audit → Production (if needed) → Integrate to WT‑tabs & insert pins (WT‑202/WT‑104/WT‑201).
END — White Tab 003▸ Entry — WT‑202 Discovery Packet (Julian Rivera — Total Restoration, Inc.) v2.1