Skip to content

White Tab 106A — SERVPRO Field Incident Video: Bathroom Sink Supply/Shutoff Failure (G21)

GUARDRAIL: WHITE — FACT REPOSITORY ONLY

Facts & source pinpoints only. No strategy, no argument, no legal opinions. All quotations are "as reported" unless exact text appears in a cited source.

A) Purpose (facts-only)

Authenticate and index tenant-captured original iPhone media documenting a SERVPRO field incident (bathroom sink supply/shutoff failure) at G21 (226 Franklin St., entrance 97 Green St.) on 2023-07-13. The assets include 1 video and 12 still photographs imported directly from the iPhone device; these are to be preserved, hashed, Bates-stamped, and cross-referenced to the July-2023 communications packet (WT-111).

Scope Note: This tab documents the valve break incident only (SERVPRO field incident documented on video and stills). Rainstorm-related re-flood conditions (discovered 2023-07-12; standing water; pipes documented as uncapped in the email thread; ceiling leak conditions) are documented separately in WT-116 Section B.4.1.

B) Event & Timeline Anchors (mechanical pinpoints)

When (local) What Who Where White Tab Pinpoint
2023-07-13 (time 14:46:15 local; QuickTime metadata) SERVPRO field incident — bathroom sink supply/shutoff failure: flexible sink feed line routed into an open wall drain opening with water discharged at full pressure; valve body also dripping steadily onto floor (captured on video). Moisture/mold staining on bathroom walls observed in stills. SERVPRO crew; Christian Gray G21 bathroom WT-106A (this tab) 106A-PIN-VID-A
2023-07-12 Tenant discovers rainstorm re-flood — standing water already present from prior storm; sends "G21 Flooded Again!" email/photos. Gray; recipients per thread Email WT-116 B.4.1 116-PIN-2023JULY-RAINSTORM
2023-07-13 Tenant distributes additional re-flood email/photos documenting conditions same day as valve break (see WT-111 files list and Bates). Gray; recipients per thread Email WT-111 106A-PIN-111-A

C) Source & Provenance (facts-only)

  • Origin: Captured by Christian Gray on iPhone; original files provided in this thread (1 video clip; 12 JPEG stills).

  • Uploaded filenames (as received):

  • Video: 7_13_2023_Broken_Shut-ff_Valve_and_Plumbing_Leak.mov

  • Stills (12): IMG_4689 2.JPG, IMG_4688 3.JPG, IMG_4687 2.JPG, IMG_4686 3.JPG, IMG_4685 2.JPG, IMG_4684 2.JPG, IMG_4683 3.JPG, IMG_4682 2.JPG, IMG_4681 2.JPG, IMG_4680 2.JPG, IMG_4679 3.JPG, IMG_4678 2.JPG.

  • Import: "Original iPhone import" per tenant; no edits represented or claimed at this stage.

  • Chronology linkage: Same-day emails/photos are preserved in WT-111 (Bates 111-001–111-037; media placeholder reserved).

D) Media Index (facts-only; EXIF verified 2023-07-13)

Storage note: Photos S-1 through S-12 are stored in the WT-111 media folder with standardized naming (WT-111_Photo_XX_IMG_XXXX.jpeg). These are the same files (byte-for-byte identical) documented in both tabs; WT-106A links to the WT-111 copies to avoid duplication.

v1.7.2 Note: Columns reordered for usability — Scene Description and View links moved to visible columns; technical metadata shifted right.

v1.7.3 Note: Valve incident description updated to include valve body drip (visible in video) in addition to feed line discharge.

D.1 Video Asset

ID Scene Description View Duration Filename DateTime Device SHA-256
V-1 Bathroom sink supply/shutoff failure: flexible sink feed line routed into an open wall drain opening with water discharged at full pressure; valve body also dripping steadily onto floor View 72.09 s 7_13_2023_Broken_Shut-ff_Valve_and_Plumbing_Leak.mov 2023-07-13 14:46:15 -0400 Apple iPhone X (iOS 16.5.1) 51ab0110...a2acb60

Metadata note: The video file contains multiple time-related tags. For incident dating, this tab relies on the Apple QuickTime com.apple.quicktime.creationdate tag (2023-07-13 14:46:15 -0400). A separate generic creation_time tag may reflect later export/handling.

D.2 Still Photo Assets (12 photos — descriptions based on visual inspection)

ID Scene Description View Filename (original) EXIF DateTime
S-1 Corroded copper pipes with green verdigris patina; open circular drain hole in wall (rusted rim); dark mold spotting on painted wall surface; plumbing connections at base View IMG_4678 2.JPG 2023-07-13 14:48:08
S-2 Close-up of wall surface showing extensive dark mold growth pattern; spotting distributed across painted surface View IMG_4679 3.JPG 2023-07-13 14:48:11
S-3 Wall surface with mold spotting pattern; rust/water staining visible at lower portion; pipe visible at bottom edge View IMG_4680 2.JPG 2023-07-13 14:48:14
S-4 Horizontal corroded pipe crossing frame; heavy mold spotting on wall behind; deteriorated wall area at pipe penetration View IMG_4681 2.JPG 2023-07-13 14:48:16
S-5 Pipe corrosion detail; wall mold/moisture staining pattern (similar view to S-4) View IMG_4682 2.JPG 2023-07-13 14:48:17
S-6 Sink shutoff valve with braided stainless steel flexible supply line; valve mounted on wood block; water/rust staining on wall behind valve; supply line extends upward View IMG_4683 3.JPG 2023-07-13 14:48:21
S-7 Toilet area showing toilet bowl with discoloration; white baseboard with dark spotting; tile floor with debris; wall staining behind toilet View IMG_4684 2.JPG 2023-07-13 15:11:24
S-8 Corner view showing white baseboard; black rubber pipes on tile floor; water damage/staining at wall-floor junction; rust staining on wall View IMG_4685 2.JPG 2023-07-13 15:11:27
S-9 Wide bathroom view: toilet with rust/mineral staining; wall showing patched areas, water staining, and flexible supply line; black rubber pipes coiled on tile floor View IMG_4686 3.JPG 2023-07-13 15:11:32
S-10 Exposed wall cavity: wood studs (2x4) with visible dark mold growth on framing; water staining pattern running down drywall back; subfloor visible at bottom View IMG_4687 2.JPG 2023-07-13 15:11:53
S-11 Wall cavity detail showing drywall back with water staining pattern; mold growth at base; construction debris on floor View IMG_4688 3.JPG 2023-07-13 15:11:58
S-12 Corner showing peeled/removed wall covering revealing substrate; partial tile removal; mold spotting visible on exposed surfaces; wall assembly showing multiple layers View IMG_4689 2.JPG 2023-07-13 15:11:59

Device (all photos): Apple iPhone X

D.3 Photo Evidence Summary (facts-only)

Photos S-1 through S-12 directly document the following conditions in G21 bathroom on 2023-07-13:

Plumbing Configuration (valve break context):

  • Sink shutoff valve with braided flexible supply line (S-6, S-9)
  • Open drain hole in wall with rusted rim (S-1)
  • Corroded copper supply pipes with verdigris patina (S-1, S-4, S-5)
  • Black rubber pipes/hoses on floor (S-8, S-9)

Moisture/Mold Conditions (visible in photos):

  • Dark mold spotting on painted wall surfaces (S-1, S-2, S-3, S-4, S-5)
  • Mold growth on exposed wood framing/studs in wall cavity (S-10)
  • Water staining patterns on drywall back (S-10, S-11)
  • Rust/water staining at wall-floor junction (S-8)
  • Toilet bowl with rust/mineral staining (S-7, S-9)

Structural/Finish Conditions:

  • Exposed wall cavities showing framing (S-10, S-11, S-12)
  • Removed/damaged wall coverings (S-12)
  • White baseboard with dark spotting (S-7, S-8)
  • Tile floor with debris (S-7, S-8, S-9)

Cross-reference note: Mold conditions visible in these photos also support WT-116 B.4.3 (mold documentation window, 2023-07-12 to 07-17), documenting visible mold in areas certified as "cleared" after the ALC PRV (2021-08-03).

E) Relationship to Other White Tabs (facts-only)

  • WT-111 — July 2023 Re-Flood Email / Photo Packet: contemporaneous distribution of photos and notice emails during July 12–17, 2023; the 106A media set is part of the same event window and should be cross-Batesed. Photos S-1 through S-12 are stored in WT-111 media folder.
  • WT-116 — G21 Leaks Documentation: Documents the full July 2023 event sequence:
  • B.4.1 (rainstorm re-flood discovery, 2023-07-12) — separate event with different proximate cause (rainstorm-related water intrusion conditions).
  • B.4.2 (SERVPRO valve break, 2023-07-13) — this tab's scope (SERVPRO field incident (video/stills)).
  • B.4.3 (mold documentation window, 2023-07-12 to 07-17) — consequence evidence; mold conditions visible in S-1 through S-12 support this section.

F) Bates Plan (mechanical)

Prefix: G21-106A-[6-digit]

  1. Video V-1 storyboard + container report → G21-106A-000001+
  2. Stills S-1…S-12 in capture order → G21-106A-000200+
  3. EXIF/QuickTime manifests & hash sheet → G21-106A-000400+

G) ESI / Media Handling Protocol (facts-only)

  1. Preserve natives: retain the original .MOV and .JPG files; no recompression.
  2. Hashing: compute SHA-256 for every file; store in hash manifest (CSV).
  3. EXIF/QuickTime extraction: record Make/Model, DateTimeOriginal, GPS (if present); QuickTime creation_time and duration.
  4. Storyboard: export stills of key video frames with printed timecode.
  5. Load file: produce Concordance .DAT/.OPT with Bates, NativeLink, Parent-Child family links.
  6. Chain-of-custody: complete form documenting source and handoffs.

H) Verification Status (facts-only)

  • Capture provenance: Tenant states "original iPhone import"; EXIF verification COMPLETE — all 12 photos show Apple iPhone X, dated 2023-07-13.
  • Editing: None claimed; verification TBD via hash comparison to device (if available).
  • Photo descriptions: Visual inspection of all 12 photos COMPLETE — descriptions in Section D.2.
  • Media links: COMPLETE — All 13 media files have clickable links in Sections C and D.

END — White Tab 106A — SERVPRO Field Incident Video v1.7.3