Blue Tab 100A — G21 Post-Flood Damage Documentation¶
GUARDRAIL: BLUE — G21 BASE DAMAGES
This tab is part of Blue Volume 05 — G21 Base Damages. It documents compensable losses arising directly from the October 2019 flood at Unit G21, 97 Green Street, Brooklyn, NY 11222. All figures in this section are base damages only — before punitive multipliers, interest, or policy adjustments.
Navigation
Previous: Tab 100 — Pre-Flood Condition Baseline
Next: Tab 101 — Property Damage Overview
POSTURE NOTE — Post-Flood Visual Documentation¶
This document presents 156 photographs and 25 videos documenting the October 2019 flood event at Unit G21, 97 Green Street, Brooklyn, NY. The media captures active flooding, standing water depths of 4–5 inches, and damage to personal property including IKEA MALM bedroom furniture documented in Tab 100's pre-flood baseline. Video recordings carry preserved QuickTime creation timestamps beginning at 00:19:39 EDT on October 14, 2019, spanning 9 recording windows through October 24.
The photographs and videos provide visual evidence supporting damage claims across multiple categories: property destruction (Tab 101), business income losses from studio destruction (Tab 102), and the necessity of alternative housing (Tab 103). Key evidentiary elements include measured water depths, furniture submersion documenting wicking damage to particleboard, brand identification across 10 manufacturers, mold contamination on bedding and personal property, and the extent of flooding throughout the unit.
All media follows the table format established in White Tab 116 (G21 Leaks Documentation), Parts D.2 and D.3.
Section 1: Source Authentication¶
1.1 Chain of Custody¶
| Stage | Date | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Original Capture | October 2019 | iPhone photographs and video taken during active flood event |
| Contemporaneous Transmission | October 2019 | Media sent via text/email to Attorney Eric Sherman |
| iPhone Loss | ~2020–2021 | Hard factory reset after screen replacement destroyed originals |
| Recovery | Subsequent | Attorney Sherman returned copies to client |
| Current Status | 2026 | These are the only existing copies (156 photos + 25 videos) |
Standard chain of custody: iPhone → Attorney Sherman (Oct 2019) → Returned copies
1.2 Metadata Status¶
Photos: EXIF data stripped during text/email transmission. The original iPhone photographs contained full EXIF data (DateTimeOriginal, GPS coordinates, device information), but this metadata was not preserved during transmission to counsel.
Videos: QuickTime creation timestamps preserved on all 19 native MOV files (V-002 through V-017, V-023 through V-025). HandBrake date tags preserved on 5 re-encoded files (V-018 through V-022). V-001 was also re-encoded via HandBrake but its creation date was not preserved. In total, 24 of 25 videos carry preserved date/time metadata. See Section 3.2 for the complete video metadata table.
1.3 Date Verification — Four Independent Sources¶
October 2019 documentation dates are verified by multiple independent sources:
| Source | Evidence |
|---|---|
| Preserved Video Timestamps | QuickTime creation dates on native MOV files document active flood recording beginning at 00:19:39 EDT on October 14, 2019 (V-002), with additional timestamped recordings at 00:20:11 (V-016), 00:20:51 (V-025), and 00:22:26 (V-017). Subsequent videos carry timestamps spanning October 14 afternoon through October 24, 2019 across 9 recording windows. Two devices documented: iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) and iPhone 6s (iOS 12.1.2). |
| Attorney Records | Eric Sherman's email/text records show contemporaneous receipt in October 2019 |
| Insurance Records | Great American E&S date of loss: October 14, 2019 (WT-103) |
| Visual Corroboration | Photo 026 shows pumpkin (seasonal autumn confirmation); photos show active water intrusion with ripple patterns consistent with documented flood event |
1.4 Attorney Verification¶
Attorney Eric Sherman can provide declaration or testimony confirming:
- Receipt of photographs and videos via text/email in October 2019
- Context of transmission (client documenting active flood emergency)
- Timestamp records from email/text communications
This third-party contemporaneous receipt, combined with preserved QuickTime video timestamps, provides robust authentication. Attorney records establish independent verification of the October 2019 documentation period, while native video metadata provides precise date and time confirmation for each recording.
1.5 Technical Specifications — Photos¶
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Resolution | 1500 x 2000 pixels (compressed during transmission) |
| Format | JPEG |
| Original Device | iPhone (model unknown — device lost) |
| Compression Source | Text/email transmission protocol |
| EXIF Status | Stripped |
| Total Photo Count | 156 |
| Authentication | STRONG — third-party contemporaneous receipt by counsel |
1.6 Technical Specifications — Video¶
Total videos: 25 (V-001 through V-025). See Section 3.2 for complete per-video metadata table.
| Parameter | Summary |
|---|---|
| Devices | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) — 22 videos; iPhone 6s (iOS 12.1.2) — 3 videos (V-016, V-017, V-025) |
| Video codecs | H.264 Main/High (20 videos); HEVC Main (5 videos: V-007, V-008, V-009, V-011, V-023) |
| Resolutions | 720x1280, 1080x1920, 540x960, 1280x720, 1920x1080 (portrait and landscape) |
| Frame rate | 30 fps (iPhone X); 29.97 fps (iPhone 6s) |
| Audio codec | AAC mono 44.1 kHz (all 25) |
| Native MOV files | 19 (V-002 through V-017, V-023 through V-025) — QuickTime creation timestamps preserved |
| HandBrake re-encodes | 6 (V-001, V-018 through V-022) — HandBrake date tags preserved on V-018 through V-022; V-001 creation date not preserved |
| Metadata status | 24 of 25 videos carry preserved date/time metadata (QT creation date or HandBrake date tag) |
| Date span | October 14, 2019 (00:19:39 EDT) through October 24, 2019 (11:08:27 EDT) |
| Recording windows | 9 distinct sessions across 6 calendar days |
1.7 HD Archive Note¶
All photographs were received as compressed copies (average ~300–400 KB per image, ~1500x2000 px). Original full-resolution captures were lost with the iPhone factory reset. The compressed versions are the best available copies and are accepted as evidentiary originals given the documented chain of custody through Attorney Sherman. Of the 25 videos, 19 are native MOV files with preserved QuickTime metadata; 6 were re-encoded via HandBrake 1.10.2 during the transmission/return process (compression is analogous to JPEG photo compression and does not affect evidentiary content). Five browser-incompatible HEVC videos were additionally re-encoded to MP4 for web display (v1.1.2); original metadata classification is unchanged.
Section 2: Photo Archive — October 2019 Flood Event¶
Total photographs: 156 Quality: 153 GOOD / 3 POOR (seq 003, 009, 048) Evidentiary: 103 HIGH / 46 MEDIUM / 7 LOW Date source (all): October 2019 (Attorney Sherman contemporaneous receipt)
2.1 Complete Photo Index¶
| Seq | Scene Description | View | Filename | Original | Date Source | Quality | Evidentiary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 001 | Eagles concert poster with visible text 'Tickets on Sale Friday, October 18' providing independent temporal verification of October 2019 documentation date | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_001_EaglesPoster_TemporalMarker.jpeg | IMG_0192.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 002 | Ceiling/wall junction showing pipe fitting with extensive mold growth pattern and water staining indicating ongoing water intrusion source | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_002_CeilingPipeFitting_MoldPattern.jpeg | IMG_4162.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 003 | Bedroom area showing flood conditions with inflatable air mattress visible, documenting displacement conditions | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_003_BedroomFlood_AirMattress.jpeg | IMG_4167.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | POOR | HIGH |
| 004 | Wide bedroom view showing active water with visible ripple patterns on surface indicating ongoing water intrusion | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_004_BedroomOverview_ActiveFlooding.jpeg | IMG_4168.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 005 | IKEA MALM 6-drawer dresser with mirror submerged in standing water, particleboard base in direct flood contact | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_005_MALMDresser_FloodWater.jpeg | IMG_4169.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 006 | Living area furniture in standing water documenting flood extent beyond bedroom | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_006_LivingArea_CouchInWater.jpeg | IMG_4170.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 007 | Pair of MALM nightstands in standing water with particleboard wicking damage | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_007_MALMNightstands_StandingWater.jpeg | IMG_4171.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 008 | Tape measure placed against surface showing approximately 4-inch water depth measurement | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_008_TapeMeasure_WaterDepth4in.jpeg | IMG_4172.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 009 | Tape measure over submerged oriental rug showing approximately 5-inch water depth | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_009_TapeMeasure_RugSubmerged5in.jpeg | IMG_4173.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | POOR | HIGH |
| 010 | Flooded hallway with storage shelving and salvage buckets documenting unit-wide flooding | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_010_Hallway_FloodedCorridor.jpeg | IMG_4176.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 011 | Kitchen counter with glass fruit bowl (tomatoes, bananas) on butcher block near gas stove; living space context | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_011_Kitchen_FruitBowl_ContextShot.jpeg | IMG_4177.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | LOW |
| 012 | Ceramic bowl with onions and dried herbs on counter; MALM dresser and bed visible through doorway in background | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_012_Kitchen_OnionBowl_MALMBackground.jpeg | IMG_4178.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 013 | Air mattress/inflatable bed set up in living area next to sectional couch; TV and studio monitor visible; displacement sleeping arrangement | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_013_LivingArea_AirMattress_Displacement.jpeg | IMG_4183.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 014 | Travertine coffee table with Samsung and Fire TV remotes; visible water staining and mineral deposits on stone surface | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_014_CoffeeTable_WaterStaining_Remotes.jpeg | IMG_4184.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 015 | Nightstand/shelf with multiple remotes (Spectrum cable, Samsung TV, GE AC, Lasko fan); water staining visible; Samsung speaker | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_015_Nightstand_MultipleRemotes_WaterStaining.jpeg | IMG_4185.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 016 | MALM bed frame with integrated headboard shelves; gray pillows and bedding; Tab 100 furniture connection | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_016_Bedroom_MALMBed_Headboard.jpeg | IMG_4186.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 017 | Bookshelf near white structural column; standing water on concrete floor with debris; water jugs visible; cables in water | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_017_LivingArea_Bookshelf_StandingWater.jpeg | IMG_4187.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 018 | Red and orange Home Depot 5-gallon buckets (salvage/mitigation); wet carpet/rug with water staining; road case visible | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_018_Hallway_HomeDepotBuckets_WetRug.jpeg | IMG_4188.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 019 | Kitchen island/counter with umbrella, stacked papers and documents; water staining visible on butcher block surface | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_019_KitchenIsland_WaterStaining_Papers.jpeg | IMG_4189.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 020 | Kitchen counter showing water droplets and pooling on butcher block surface; wet dishes/plates visible; active water intrusion evidence | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_020_KitchenCounter_WaterPooling_ActiveDrip.jpeg | IMG_4190.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 021 | Butcher block counter corner showing seam separation and joint damage from water exposure; structural wood damage | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_021_KitchenCounter_SeamSeparation_WaterDamage.jpeg | IMG_4191.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 022 | Gray sectional couch close-up with decorative pillow; white debris/particles visible on fabric; burgundy rug beneath | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_022_Sectional_CloseUp_FabricDebris.jpeg | IMG_4192.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 023 | Sectional couch with striped decorative pillow and patterned blanket; burgundy rug visible | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_023_Sectional_StripedPillow_Blanket.jpeg | IMG_4193.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | LOW |
| 024 | Sectional couch wide shot showing pillows, tie draped over back; flooded floor and hallway visible in background | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_024_Sectional_WideShot_FloodedBackground.jpeg | IMG_4194.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 025 | Two travertine coffee tables showing severe water damage with bubbling, mineral deposits, and surface deterioration | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_025_CoffeeTables_SevereWaterDamage_MineralDeposits.jpeg | IMG_4195.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 026 | Four white bar stools at kitchen island with visible water pooling on seats; pumpkin on counter (October marker); bedroom and bookshelves in background | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_026_KitchenIsland_BarStools_WaterPooling.jpeg | IMG_4196.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 027 | Standing water on concrete floor with window light reflection; under TV console area; barstool base visible in water | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_027_Floor_StandingWater_WindowReflection.jpeg | IMG_4197.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 028 | Deep standing water at exposed brick wall; stool base and electrical cables submerged; safety hazard documentation | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_028_ExposedBrick_DeepWater_CablesSubmerged.jpeg | IMG_4198.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 029 | TV console/entertainment center with cables and wires in standing water; wet carpet edge visible; electronics at risk | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_029_TVConsole_CablesInWater_RugEdge.jpeg | IMG_4199.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 030 | Travertine coffee table with water staining patterns; burgundy oriental rug; gray sectional visible | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_030_CoffeeTable_WaterStaining_RugCouch.jpeg | IMG_4200.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 031 | Close-up of coffee table surface showing detailed water damage patterns, mineral deposits, debris, and staining | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_031_CoffeeTable_DetailShot_MineralDeposits.jpeg | IMG_4201.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 032 | Light wood cube end table with glass top showing severe water damage; wet paper napkin on surface; water staining and mineral deposits visible on wood; gray sectional visible in background | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_032_EndTable_GlassTop_WaterStaining.jpeg | IMG_4202.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 033 | Close-up of gray sectional sofa cushion bottom edge showing clear water tide line; dark staining visible along fabric where water reached; red rug visible below | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_033_Sectional_CushionEdge_WaterLine.jpeg | IMG_4203.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 034 | Gray sectional corner section with striped decorative pillow; shows furniture context; minimal visible damage in this shot; debris particles visible on cushions | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_034_Sectional_CornerSection_Pillows.jpeg | IMG_4204.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | LOW |
| 035 | Gray sectional ottoman/chaise piece showing water stain at upper left corner; visible tide mark on fabric; debris particles scattered on surface | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_035_Sectional_Ottoman_WaterStaining.jpeg | IMG_4205.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 036 | Wide shot of flooded living area; concrete floor with water residue and dark debris; two water jugs for mitigation; bookshelf with books at risk; electrical cables on wet floor; white column visible | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_036_LivingArea_FloodedFloor_WaterJugs.jpeg | IMG_4206.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 037 | Same scene as 036 from slightly different angle; flooded concrete floor; water jugs; bookshelf; cables in water; debris pattern on floor | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_037_LivingArea_FloodedFloor_Bookshelf.jpeg | IMG_4207.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 038 | Yellow/beige textured comforter on bed showing large irregular water stain; dark discoloration pattern clearly visible; demonstrates water reached bedding level | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_038_Bedding_Comforter_WaterStain.jpeg | IMG_4208.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 039 | MALM platform bed with built-in headboard shelving (Tab 100 connection); birch wood frame; purple/gray sheets; stained comforter visible at corner; Persian rug below bed | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_039_Bedroom_MALMBed_WideShot.jpeg | IMG_4209.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 040 | Close-up of Persian/Oriental rug next to MALM bed frame; red and blue traditional pattern; rug appears damp or shows water exposure; edge of bed frame visible | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_040_Bedroom_PersianRug_WaterDamage.jpeg | IMG_4210.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 041 | White wall meeting concrete floor showing clear flood tide line; debris and residue pattern on floor indicating water height; wood furniture edge visible at left | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_041_Wall_FloodLine_DebrisFloor.jpeg | IMG_4211.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 042 | Birch wood bookshelf/room divider showing flood debris pattern on concrete floor; gray sectional visible behind; Persian rug edge at right; demonstrates flood extent in living area | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_042_Bookshelf_RoomDivider_FloorDebris.jpeg | IMG_4212.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 043 | Close-up of white/cream linen curtain showing severe brown water staining and clear tide line; dark discoloration from water wicking up fabric; demonstrates flood height reached curtain level | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_043_Curtain_SevereWaterStaining_TideLine.jpeg | IMG_4213.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 044 | Active flooding on concrete floor; professional road case/equipment case in water; water jugs for mitigation; bookshelf visible; demonstrates studio equipment at risk from flood | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_044_FloodedFloor_EquipmentCase_StudioGear.jpeg | IMG_4214.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 045 | Black duffel/sleeping bag placed on top of equipment road case to elevate above flood water; active flood visible on floor; demonstrates salvage mitigation efforts during flooding | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_045_SalvageEffort_DuffelOnCase_FloodedFloor.jpeg | IMG_4215.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 046 | Closet or utility area with dark carpet runner showing extensive water saturation; cardboard boxes visible; clothing rack; demonstrates flood reached storage areas | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_046_Closet_WetCarpetRunner_Boxes.jpeg | IMG_4216.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 047 | Ceiling showing significant damage with hole/crack exposing underlying structure; water damage pattern visible; demonstrates structural impact from water intrusion | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_047_Ceiling_HoleDamage_StructuralExposure.jpeg | IMG_4217.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 048 | Ceiling showing water stain pattern with exposed wiring/electrical connection visible; demonstrates water reached electrical infrastructure | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_048_Ceiling_WaterStain_ExposedWiring.jpeg | IMG_4218.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | POOR | MEDIUM |
| 049 | Ceiling corner near window showing extensive water damage pattern; cable/wire running along ceiling; vent visible; wood-framed window; demonstrates water intrusion from above | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_049_Ceiling_WaterDamagePattern_WindowCorner.jpeg | IMG_4219.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 050 | Bamboo hardwood flooring showing water staining and damage marks; visible discoloration patterns from flood exposure; demonstrates hardwood floor damage | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_050_BambooFloor_WaterStaining_Damage.jpeg | IMG_4220.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 051 | Wide shot of bamboo hardwood flooring with extensive water damage patterns; multiple stain marks visible across planks; rug edge visible at corner | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_051_BambooFloor_WaterDamage_WideShot.jpeg | IMG_4221.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 052 | Studio area with dark carpet showing water exposure; guitar case visible (red/black); wrapped items stored against wall; wall base showing water damage staining; doorway threshold visible | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_052_Studio_GuitarCase_WetCarpet_WallDamage.jpeg | IMG_4222.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 053 | Close-up of white wall showing water damage causing paint blistering and bubbling; dark carpet at floor level; demonstrates water wicking up wall material | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_053_Wall_WaterBlistering_BubblingPaint.jpeg | IMG_4223.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 054 | Bentwood/plywood chair (Jacobsen style) showing surface wear and potential water damage; chrome bar stool visible in background; demonstrates furniture damage from flood exposure | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_054_BentwoodChair_SurfaceDamage_BarStool.jpeg | IMG_4224.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 055 | Close-up of baseboard and wall junction meeting concrete floor; visible water damage pattern; demonstrates flood height at wall base | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_055_Baseboard_WaterDamage_ConcreteJunction.jpeg | IMG_4225.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 056 | Ceiling showing water damage pattern with visible cracking and paint deterioration; demonstrates water intrusion from above unit | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_056_Ceiling_WaterDamagePattern_Cracking.jpeg | IMG_4226.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 057 | Curtain showing water staining; industrial ceiling with exposed beams and ductwork visible; demonstrates building-wide water damage context | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_057_Curtain_WaterStaining_IndustrialCeiling.jpeg | IMG_4227.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 058 | Kitchen area with two white LEM-style bar stools showing clear water/debris staining in seat wells; butcher block counter; kitchen island visible; demonstrates water reached seating areas | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_058_Kitchen_LEMStools_WaterStaining.jpeg | IMG_4228.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 059 | Wide shot showing curtain with water staining near floor; concrete floor with debris; bar stool base; sectional sofa edge; blue bedding visible in background; demonstrates unit-wide flood extent | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_059_Curtain_FloorLevel_WaterStaining_WideShot.jpeg | IMG_4229.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 060 | Kitchen context showing butcher block surface with fruit bowl; stove area visible; stainless refrigerator; demonstrates pre-flood kitchen condition | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_060_Kitchen_ButcherBlock_ContextShot.jpeg | IMG_4230.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | LOW |
| 061 | Kitchen context showing professional-style gas range; butcher block counter; fruit bowl; ceramic dishes; demonstrates kitchen setup and condition | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_061_Kitchen_Stove_ContextShot.jpeg | IMG_4231.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | LOW |
| 062 | Kitchen counter with ceramic bowl containing onions and dried herbs next to gas stove with pot | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_062_Kitchen_ProduceBowl_ContextShot.jpeg | IMG_4232.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | LOW |
| 063 | Closet interior showing hanging clothes on wooden hangers with visible water staining on bottom shelf | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_063_Closet_HangingClothes_WaterStainedShelf.jpeg | IMG_4235.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 064 | Close-up of Stanton Rug Company handcrafted label showing water staining and debris on rug surface | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_064_StantonRug_LabelCloseUp_WaterDamage.jpeg | IMG_4241.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 065 | Rolled Stanton rug on wet concrete floor with Shop-Vac visible and water pooling beneath | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_065_StantonRug_RolledOnWetFloor_ShopVac.jpeg | IMG_4242.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 066 | Stanton rug label inverted showing underside with floor visible below edge | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_066_StantonRug_LabelInverted_EdgeDetail.jpeg | IMG_4243.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 067 | Alternate angle of rolled Stanton rug on wet concrete showing water pooling and floor tiles | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_067_StantonRug_RolledAlternateAngle.jpeg | IMG_4244.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 068 | Guitar hard case open showing plush orange interior lining with severe dark water staining along bottom edge | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_068_GuitarCase_InteriorWaterStaining.jpeg | IMG_4245.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 069 | Close-up of guitar case interior showing water tide line and staining detail on plush lining | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_069_GuitarCase_WaterDamageCloseUp.jpeg | IMG_4246.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 070 | Building hallway with worker removing drywall exposing pink insulation and Golden Drum sign visible near door 621 | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_070_Hallway_RemediationWork_DrywallRemoval.jpeg | IMG_4248.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 071 | Building hallway with American Package Company Inc mailbox sign visible and exposed insulation at wall base with wet debris-covered floor | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_071_Hallway_APCOMailbox_InsulationExposed.jpeg | IMG_4249.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 072 | Building hallway with exposed pink insulation after drywall removal and debris piles on wet floor with worker visible | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_072_Hallway_RemediationDebris_InsulationExposed.jpeg | IMG_4250.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 073 | Close-up of pink fiberglass insulation showing dark water staining and rust on metal stud with drywall debris below | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_073_Hallway_InsulationCloseUp_WaterStaining.jpeg | IMG_4251.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 074 | Close-up of insulation base showing severe dark discoloration from water wicking and standing water on floor | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_074_Hallway_InsulationBase_SevereWaterDamage.jpeg | IMG_4252.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 075 | Close-up of pink insulation with dark water staining at bottom edge and drywall debris on floor | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_075_Hallway_InsulationDetail_DarkStaining.jpeg | IMG_4253.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 076 | Wall cavity exposed showing severe mold/contamination on sheathing behind pulled-back insulation with dark organic growth | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_076_Hallway_WallCavity_MoldContamination.jpeg | IMG_4254.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 077 | Remediation tools on work surface including Makita drill and battery plus Stanley FatMax tape measure and WD-40 can | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_077_G21_RemediationTools_MakitaDrill.jpeg | IMG_4259.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | LOW |
| 078 | Black suede loafers held over sink with running water showing water damage and debris/staining on fabric | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_078_G21_SuedeLoafers_WaterDamage.jpeg | IMG_4265.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 079 | Interior corridor wall and baseboard showing water staining marks on wall with wet concrete floor | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_079_G21_CorridorBaseboard_WaterStaining.jpeg | IMG_4266.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 080 | Electric guitar in open case on desk showing water staining damage on wood desk surface next to leather desk pad | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_080_G21_GuitarOnDesk_WaterStaining.jpeg | IMG_4267.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 081 | MALM-style birch nightstand with drawer open showing circular water stain rings on top and water damage inside drawer | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_081_G21_MALMNightstand_WaterDamageDrawer.jpeg | IMG_4268.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 082 | MALM birch-veneer nightstand with drawer pulled open; water staining and mineral deposits visible on drawer bottom interior; concrete floor with cracks visible; bar stool legs in background | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_082_G21_MALMNightstand_DrawerWaterDamage.jpeg | IMG_4269.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 083 | Close-up of MALM nightstand drawer interior showing circular water stain rings at lower left; surface bubbling and warping; mineral and debris deposits concentrated in corner | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_083_G21_MALMNightstand_DrawerCloseUp_MineralDeposits.jpeg | IMG_4270.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 084 | White quilted comforter draped showing severe dark grey/black mold growth following the quilted stitch pattern; bookshelf with books visible in background | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_084_Bedding_Comforter_MoldGrowthPattern.jpeg | IMG_4271.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 085 | Same white quilted comforter from wider angle showing full extent of dark mold contamination along quilted grid pattern; bookshelf background | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_085_Bedding_Comforter_MoldGrowthWideShot.jpeg | IMG_4272.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 086 | Beautyrest-branded mattress pad laid out showing repeated brand logo across surface; visible water staining and discoloration; bundled sheets at top; blue tarp at edge; person's foot visible | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_086_Bedding_BeautyrestMattressPad_WaterStaining.jpeg | IMG_4273.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 087 | White herringbone-weave bath towel held up showing water staining and yellowish-brown discoloration in center area; blue fabric behind; books visible at lower right | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_087_Linens_WhiteTowel_WaterStaining.jpeg | IMG_4274.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 088 | Gold/mustard bath towel laid on concrete floor showing severe dark mold staining and contamination across much of surface; white towel at lower right; person's feet visible at top in black sneakers; cable on floor | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_088_Linens_GoldTowel_SevereMoldStaining.jpeg | IMG_4275.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 089 | White comforter spread showing extensive dark staining and mold patterns covering majority of surface; quilted pattern visible beneath contamination; wider spread than 084-085 | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_089_Bedding_Comforter_ExtensiveMoldContamination.jpeg | IMG_4276.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 090 | White bedding/comforter section showing numerous dark spots scattered across surface consistent with mold colonization; IKEA blue bag visible at lower right; green fabric at lower left | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_090_Bedding_Comforter_ScatteredMoldSpots.jpeg | IMG_4277.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 091 | Large white comforter spread out showing extensive water staining and grey-brown mold contamination across surface; mirror in background reflecting bedding; lavender sheet visible at top | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_091_Bedding_Comforter_FullExtentMoldDamage.jpeg | IMG_4278.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 092 | White quilted comforter with severe dark grey-black mold growth following quilted stitch pattern; bamboo flooring visible at bottom edge; mirror at lower right; black trash bag at upper right | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_092_Bedding_Comforter_MoldContamination_AlternateAngle.jpeg | IMG_4279.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 093 | Lavender cotton fitted sheet spread out showing dark water staining and discoloration across surface; wrinkled; bamboo floor and stained white towel visible at bottom edge; shoe at upper right | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_093_Bedding_LavenderSheet_WaterStaining.jpeg | IMG_4280.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 094 | Same lavender sheet spread more flat showing subtle yellowish staining at upper left; cables and shoe visible at top; blue tarp edge at right; more even lighting | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_094_Bedding_LavenderSheet_SubtleStaining.jpeg | IMG_4281.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 095 | White bed pillow partially removed from dark grey pillowcase; prominent yellowish-brown water stain visible in center of pillow; on concrete floor with cable visible | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_095_Bedding_Pillow_WaterStain_GreyPillowcase.jpeg | IMG_4282.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 096 | White bed pillow from alternate angle showing subtle discoloration and water damage; dark grey pillowcase underneath; on concrete floor with cables | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_096_Bedding_Pillow_Discoloration_AlternateAngle.jpeg | IMG_4283.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 097 | Light blue fitted sheet bundled and crumpled on concrete floor; various linens scattered — white towel at lower left and pink fabric at lower right; wide shot documenting displaced bedding | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_097_Bedding_BlueFittedSheet_FloorDocumentation.jpeg | IMG_4285.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 098 | Multiple damaged linens on concrete floor — lavender pillowcase with yellow stain; gold/brown towel; white towel; green fabric; black trash bag at upper right; wide overhead shot documenting inventory | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_098_Linens_MultipleDamagedItems_FloorOverview.jpeg | IMG_4286.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 099 | White bath towel laid flat on concrete floor showing water staining and yellowish-brown discoloration; brown towel bundled at bottom; person's feet in black sneakers at top; black trash bag visible | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_099_Linens_WhiteBathTowel_WaterStaining.jpeg | IMG_4287.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 100 | White curtain panels laid on floor showing severe vertical grey-brown water wicking streaks; rod pocket header visible; mirror/picture frame in background; demonstrates capillary action from flood water | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_100_Curtain_WhitePanels_WaterWickingPattern.jpeg | IMG_4288.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 101 | Full-height white curtains hanging from ceiling track showing vertical water staining from bottom up; blue rental dehumidifier at lower left; displaced mattress leaning against wall at right; kitchen cabinetry visible through gap; industrial ceiling exposed; wide unit interior overview | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_101_G21_CurtainsHanging_Dehumidifier_UnitOverview.jpeg | IMG_4289.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 102 | Close-up of white curtain panels showing severe dark grey-brown water staining and mold/sediment concentrated in fabric fold; contamination pattern follows crease where moisture pooled | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_102_Curtain_CloseUp_SevereStaining_MoldInFold.jpeg | IMG_4290.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 103 | Close-up of white curtain panels showing lighter but visible vertical water wicking streaks; pink-brown discoloration across multiple folds; different section of curtains from 102 | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_103_Curtain_CloseUp_LightWickingStreaks.jpeg | IMG_4291.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 104 | Close-up of curtain fold showing dark grey-brown mold or sediment contamination concentrated in fabric crease; organic growth pattern visible; similar contamination pattern to 102 at different location | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_104_Curtain_CloseUp_DarkContamination_Fold.jpeg | IMG_4292.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 105 | Overhead shot of white curtain panels removed and laid on concrete floor; extensive water staining visible across draped fabric; pleating tape header visible; sneakers at top for scale; multiple panels documenting volume of contaminated curtains | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_105_Curtain_RemovedPanels_FloorOverview.jpeg | IMG_4293.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 106 | IKEA SULTAN HULTSVIK mattress propped upright showing water stains and dark mold spots on quilted pillow-top surface; pendant lights and stainless refrigerator visible in background establishing kitchen context | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_106_Mattress_IKEASultan_WaterStains_MoldSpots.jpeg | IMG_4295.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 107 | Close-up of mattress label reading 'SULTAN HULTSVIK' with IKEA logo and 'Designed and Quality IKEA of Sweden'; care symbols visible; brand identification for replacement cost valuation | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_107_Mattress_IKEASultanHultsvik_BrandLabel.jpeg | IMG_4296.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 108 | Overhead shot of second mattress (peach quilted, Kingsdown) with blue fitted sheet/cover partially draped; dark water stains visible on blue fabric; deep red Persian rug visible underneath mattress | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_108_Mattress_Kingsdown_BlueCover_WaterStains.jpeg | IMG_4297.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 109 | Close-up of mattress manufacturer tag held by hand; readable: FG-3320-TT-F, SLEEPYS #955 ELEGANCE, Warranty Code LT, Load# 5.15-1, barcode MW78860A, materials listing (urethane foam, polyester, spring unit), Made by Kingsdown Inc Winchester VA, date visible ~2000, MADE IN USA | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_109_Mattress_Kingsdown_SleepysLabel_BrandID.jpeg | IMG_4305.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 110 | Kingsdown mattress corner showing severe black mold contamination across quilted surface; dense mold colony clusters concentrated in upper portion; manufacturer tag partially visible at lower right confirming same mattress as seq 109; total loss condition | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_110_Mattress_Kingsdown_SevereMoldContamination.jpeg | IMG_4307.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 111 | Deep red/burgundy Persian-style area rug with visible standing water pooling on surface (shiny wet reflections); Kingsdown mattress edge resting on rug; concrete floor visible at edges showing water spread beyond rug; active water damage | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_111_Bedroom_PersianRug_StandingWater.jpeg | IMG_4308.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 112 | Overhead shot of Persian rug edge with standing water pooled on concrete floor beyond fringe; dark media console/TV stand with wood shelf at left; metal lamp stand at right; water sheen visible on concrete extending past rug boundary | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_112_Bedroom_RugEdge_StandingWater_MediaConsole.jpeg | IMG_4309.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 113 | Rectangular rice paper floor lamp (IKEA style) showing water staining and discoloration at base panels; crinkled paper shade with sediment marks along lower edge; metal frame and power cord visible on concrete floor | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_113_FloorLamp_RicePaper_WaterStaining_Base.jpeg | IMG_4310.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 114 | Tall fabric hanging organizer (IKEA SKUBB style, 8+ compartments) in closet area; canvas material showing water exposure and wrinkling; wood pieces stored at base; Persian rug and white closet panel visible; mirror at right edge | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_114_Closet_FabricOrganizer_WaterExposure.jpeg | IMG_4311.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 115 | Close-up of white quilted duvet/comforter showing subtle water staining and discoloration; baffle-box construction visible; fabric shows damp yellowing consistent with flood water absorption | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_115_Duvet_White_WaterStaining_CloseUp.jpeg | IMG_4312.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 116 | Overhead shot of bedding displaced to concrete floor: white duvet/comforter, pillow, navy blue sheets/fitted sheet, light blue sheet; burgundy Persian rug edge visible at right; sneaker at bottom left for scale; concrete floor shows water residue | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_116_Bedding_FloorPile_DuvetSheetsRug.jpeg | IMG_4313.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 117 | IKEA pillow (green label visible at corner) on wet concrete floor; extensive yellow-brown water staining across white cover; horizontal crease line from water absorption; blue tarp and electrical cord visible in background | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_117_Pillow_IKEA_WaterStaining_FloorOverview.jpeg | IMG_4315.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 118 | Close-up of pillow showing yellow-brown water staining and discoloration; small brown contamination spots visible at center; fabric shows clear water absorption pattern | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_118_Pillow_CloseUp_WaterStains_Yellowing.jpeg | IMG_4316.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 119 | Close-up of pillow corner on concrete floor showing brown water spots, circular ring marks (mold colony impressions), and overall yellow discoloration; concrete floor and electrical cord visible beneath | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_119_Pillow_Corner_RingMarks_BrownSpots.jpeg | IMG_4317.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 120 | Overhead shot of pillow on concrete floor showing water staining with dark grey mold smudging and sediment transfer pattern across lower half; yellow-brown discoloration across upper portion; blue tarp edge visible at background; sneakers at bottom for scale | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_120_Pillow_MoldSmudge_FloorOverhead.jpeg | IMG_4318.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 121 | Decorative duvet cover with brown/black tree branch pattern on white background, displaced on floor; water staining visible as yellow-brown discoloration through pattern; Kingsdown mattress edge visible at bottom left; burgundy rug at lower right; concrete floor with metal stool leg at upper right | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_121_DuvetCover_BranchPattern_WaterStaining.jpeg | IMG_4320.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 122 | Close-up of decorative duvet cover with dark branch/leaf pattern on white fabric; extensive rust-orange and brown water staining across multiple areas with concentrated discoloration patches; fabric bunched showing staining penetration through folds | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_122_DuvetCover_BranchPattern_CloseUp_WaterStaining.jpeg | IMG_4321.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 123 | Green brand label on duvet cover reading 'RL LAUREN / RALPH LAUREN' with care instructions: Polyester Fill, Machine Wash Cold, Thoroughly Tumble Dry, 100% Cotton Cover, Made in China, Finished in USA; branch pattern fabric visible around label | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_123_DuvetCover_RalphLauren_BrandLabel.jpeg | IMG_4322.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 124 | Thick butcher block countertop being lifted/tilted to show severe warping along one edge; bowed curve visible in profile; positioned over 6-burner commercial gas range with cast iron grates; water ring marks on surface; hand visible holding edge | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_124_ButcherBlock_Warped_CommercialRange.jpeg | IMG_4323.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 125 | Fabric-covered lampshade with leather/brown trim edges against concrete wall; visible horizontal water tide line across middle section; moisture/water mark with shiny residue in lower portion; dark water staining on upper half; guitar case hardware visible at bottom left | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_125_Lampshade_Fabric_WaterTideLine.jpeg | IMG_4324.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 126 | Two books stacked on butcher block surface; top book: 'Facing Love Addiction' by Pia Mellody (with Andrea Wells and J. Keith Miller); bottom book partially visible: 'WILKERS-' with 'Winner of THE PULITZE[r]' text (Isabel Wilkerson, Pulitzer winner); both books show severe water damage along page edges with dark mold staining and warping; toaster oven and bag visible in background | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_126_Books_WaterDamage_MoldEdges_TwoTitles.jpeg | IMG_4332.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 127 | Long common hallway view; drywall cut at approximately 2 feet from floor on both walls exposing pink fiberglass insulation and brick behind; concrete floor wet with dark staining and white residue deposits; hand truck/dolly against right wall; open doorways at far end with light; wrapped item against right wall | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_127_Hallway_2FootCut_Remediation_WetConcrete.jpeg | IMG_4333.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 128 | Close-up of light birch wood furniture leg/base corner meeting concrete floor; dark water staining and discoloration at base where wood contacted flood water; possible mold/mildew growth at wood-floor junction; concrete floor shows moisture patterns | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_128_Furniture_BirchLeg_WaterWicking_FloorContact.jpeg | IMG_4334.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 129 | Side view of light birch wood furniture panel along concrete floor; water staining visible as dark marks along bottom edge where panel sat in flood water; wood grain clearly visible; concrete floor shows moisture residue | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_129_Furniture_BirchPanel_BaseWaterLine.jpeg | IMG_4335.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 130 | Birch wood furniture panel on concrete floor with metal L-bracket and cross-wire support hardware attached; water staining along bottom edge; bracket confirms structural furniture piece (bed frame or shelving unit); door frame and additional furniture visible in background | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_130_Furniture_BirchPanel_MetalBracket_WaterDamage.jpeg | IMG_4336.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 131 | Close-up of birch veneer furniture panel base corner on concrete floor showing water darkening and wicking at base edge where wood contacts floor | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_131_Furniture_BirchPanel_BaseWicking_CornerDetail.jpeg | IMG_4337.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 132 | Birch veneer furniture panel and leg junction at floor contact showing water darkening at base; slightly wider angle than seq 131 | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_132_Furniture_BirchPanel_BaseWicking_LegJunction.jpeg | IMG_4338.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 133 | Full IKEA MALM bed frame (birch veneer) stripped of mattress and bedding; headboard and side rails on concrete floor with metal center support and cable system visible; dark water stains on concrete floor within frame footprint; wall conduit behind | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_133_MALM_BedFrame_Full_Stripped_WaterStainFloor.jpeg | IMG_4339.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 134 | IKEA MALM attached nightstand with drawer partially open; side panel shows prominent water ring staining on birch veneer; black drawer interior visible | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_134_MALM_Nightstand_SidePanel_WaterRings.jpeg | IMG_4340.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 135 | MALM nightstand corner detail showing exposed particleboard where veneer has delaminated from water damage; white IKEA cam lock dowel visible in chipboard; dark staining on remaining veneer | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_135_MALM_Nightstand_VeneerDelamination_ExposedChipboard.jpeg | IMG_4341.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 136 | Birch veneer furniture leg base on concrete floor with water darkening at contact point; clean upper veneer contrasts with damaged base | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_136_Furniture_BirchLeg_BaseWaterDamage_CornerView.jpeg | IMG_4342.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 137 | Concrete floor along bedroom wall showing water staining and tide marks; white wall base with moisture contact; bed frame rail visible at right edge | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_137_BedroomFloor_WallPerimeter_WaterStaining_TideMarks.jpeg | IMG_4343.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 138 | Bedroom corner with concrete floor water staining extending to corner walls; exposed EMT conduit to dual-gang electrical outlet; infrastructure context | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_138_BedroomCorner_Conduit_Outlet_FloorWaterDamage.jpeg | IMG_4344.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 139 | Wider bedroom view along wall with MALM bed frame at left; extensive water staining on concrete floor; EMT conduit with clips; PAX mirrored closet doors visible at far end | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_139_Bedroom_WallView_MALMFrame_Conduit_PAXMirror.jpeg | IMG_4345.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 140 | Wide angle from bed frame area showing blue Dri-Eaz dehumidifier; MALM nightstand disassembled with drawers removed; kitchen visible in background with butcher block island and refrigerator | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_140_Bedroom_Dehumidifier_MALMDisassembled_KitchenBackground.jpeg | IMG_4346.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 141 | Widest elevated angle showing MALM bed frame corner and dehumidifier in foreground; full kitchen and living area visible in background including butcher block island and folding chairs and refrigerator and bookshelves | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_141_UnitWideAngle_BedFrame_Dehumidifier_KitchenLivingView.jpeg | IMG_4347.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 142 | Floor-level bedroom view with PAX mirrored closet doors reflecting room; EMT conduit with junction box along wall; concrete floor with water staining and mineral deposits | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_142_BedroomFloor_PAXMirror_Conduit_JunctionBox_WaterStaining.jpeg | IMG_4348.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 143 | MALM nightstand from above with drawer open showing metal slides; water ring staining prominent on birch veneer top surface; drawer interior contamination visible | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_143_MALM_Nightstand_TopView_DrawerOpen_WaterRings.jpeg | IMG_4349.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 144 | MALM nightstand close-up of top surface water stains and side panel; drawer slide hardware visible at bottom; damage extent on veneer documented | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_144_MALM_Nightstand_TopSurface_WaterStain_SideDetail.jpeg | IMG_4350.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 145 | Close-up of MALM drawer bottom interior showing water damage with mineral deposits and rust-colored staining and debris; contamination pattern consistent with standing water inside closed drawer | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_145_MALM_DrawerInterior_WaterContamination_MineralDeposits.jpeg | IMG_4351.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 146 | MALM nightstand corner showing exposed chipboard edge with water damage and veneer delamination; blue Dri-Eaz dehumidifier visible in background | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_146_MALM_Nightstand_ChipboardEdge_Delamination_Dehumidifier.jpeg | IMG_4352.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 147 | MALM drawer interior with white surface showing water staining pattern and discoloration and mold-consistent spots; evidence of water reaching inside closed drawer compartment | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_147_MALM_DrawerInterior_WaterStaining_MoldSpots.jpeg | IMG_4353.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 148 | Wide bedroom panoramic showing stripped MALM bed frame and two nightstands with drawers open; four-panel PAX mirrored closet; white walls with conduit and outlets; folding chair and table at right | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_148_Bedroom_Panoramic_MALMSet_PAXCloset_NightstandsOpen.jpeg | IMG_4354.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 149 | IKEA BILLY-consistent birch veneer bookshelf lower section with dark water damage streaks and discoloration on bottom shelf surface; shelf leg base contact with concrete floor visible | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_149_Bookshelf_BILLY_BottomShelf_WaterDamageStreaks.jpeg | IMG_4355.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 150 | Full IKEA BILLY-style birch bookshelf with recording and audio reference books remaining on upper shelves including red Master Handbook; most shelves cleared; folding chair and table with open book; guitar case at right; metal ladder at left | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_150_Bookshelf_BILLY_Full_RecordingBooks_GuitarCase_Context.jpeg | IMG_4356.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 151 | Dark grey sectional sofa close-up. Multiple cushions show prominent water wicking lines / tide marks across fabric. Gold-studded decorative pillow. Jute area rug visible beneath with curling edges. Concrete floor exposed at sofa base. | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_151_Sectional_Sofa_Cushions_WaterWicking_TideMarks_CloseUp.jpeg | IMG_4378.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 152 | Wide-angle view of L-shaped sectional with ottoman. Water tide marks on multiple cushions. Exposed brick wall, studio monitor speaker on stand, tall wood cabinet, jute rug with water damage. White and brown throw pillows. Freeman equipment context — studio monitor visible. | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_152_Sectional_Sofa_LivingRoom_WideAngle_StudioMonitor_BrickWall.jpeg | IMG_4379.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 153 | Curbside disposal documentation. Disassembled birch-veneer IKEA furniture (nightstand components, drawers, shelving) stacked on plastic-wrapped mattress at curb. NYC street visible. Total loss / forced disposal evidence. | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_153_Curbside_Disposal_IKEA_Furniture_Mattress_StreetLevel.jpeg | IMG_4380.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 154 | Wider angle of same curbside disposal. Full mattress in plastic wrap visible with IKEA birch furniture stacked on top. Drawer rails, panels, and shelf components. Confirms volume of discarded property. | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_154_Curbside_Disposal_WiderAngle_MattressFurniturePile.jpeg | IMG_4381.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
| 155 | Hand holding dark water-damaged jacket with visible 'BROOKLYN INDUSTRIES' brand label. Shot in storage/utility area. Garment shows water contamination/soiling. Filing cabinet and door visible in background. | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_155_BrooklynIndustries_Jacket_WaterDamage_BrandLabel.jpeg | IMG_4421.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | MEDIUM |
| 156 | Cardboard box of water-damaged books. Prominent: antique leather-bound 'The Americana' encyclopedia set (8+ volumes, gold lettering, severe warping/staining/mold on leather). Also visible: 'Buckminster Fuller: At Home in the Universe' (Hugh Kenner), additional titles. Major book/collectible loss documentation. | View | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_156_Books_BoxedDamage_AmericanaEncyclopedia_AntiqueLoss.jpeg | IMG_4458.jpeg | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | GOOD | HIGH |
Section 3: Video Archive — October 2019 Flood Event¶
Total videos processed: 25 (COMPLETE) Date source (all): October 2019 (Attorney Sherman contemporaneous receipt; QuickTime metadata preserved on all native MOV files V-002 through V-017, V-023 through V-025; HandBrake date tag preserved on V-018 through V-022; V-001 creation date not preserved) Note: Videos use a separate V-### sequence from the photo sequence (001–156). Recording windows: Documentation spans October 14–24, 2019 across 9 recording windows: nighttime active flood (00:19–00:22 EDT, Oct 14); afternoon aftermath (16:31–16:35 EDT, Oct 14); day-after walkthrough (17:14–17:34 EDT, Oct 15); wall cavity inspection (15:49 EDT, Oct 16); evening documentation (19:11 EDT, Oct 16); mattress/rug damage session (18:56–19:22 EDT, Oct 17); midday detail (12:43 EDT, Oct 18); afternoon sofa inspection (14:12–14:13 EDT, Oct 18); headlamp/respirator/equipment inspection (11:03–11:08 EDT, Oct 24).
3.1 Video Index¶
| Seq | Scene Description | View | Duration | Filename | Original | Date Source | Resolution | Device |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| V-001 | Bedroom panning walkthrough documenting active flood conditions. Standing water visible on floor at 00:20 with reflective surface confirming depth. Water intrusion source identified at wall/ceiling junction at 00:25 with radiating streaks. Mattress contamination streaking visible. Low-light emergency conditions throughout. | View | 0:43 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V001_BedroomFlood_MattressWallDamage_StandingWater.mp4 | IMG_4174.mp4 | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman) | 1080x720 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone (HandBrake 1.10.2 re-encode) |
| V-002 | Nighttime loft walkthrough during active flood. Exposed ceiling pipe infrastructure with pipe junctions visible (~00:20). Pendant lights, butcher block counter, red/burgundy furniture, Persian rug. Low-light emergency conditions throughout. Loft interior with exposed brick and structural columns. CROSS-REF: Probable same recording as WT-116 V-01 (ChristianGrayDocumentation.MOV) — matching timestamp, duration, resolution, device. Sherman return copy under iPhone auto-naming. | View | 1:09 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V002_LoftWalkthrough_CeilingPipes_NightFlood.mov | IMG_4163.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-14 00:19:39-0400) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-003 | Comprehensive daytime aftermath walkthrough ~16 hours post-flood. Natural sunlight. Surveys: wet/stained concrete floor; water-damaged furniture bases and Persian rug; butcher block counter with water marks; bedroom with blue bedding on red rug; grey sectional sofa with throws; displaced shoes and items on floor; cables scattered; blue storage containers; studio monitor speaker (recording equipment); bookshelf; full unit overview in daylight. | View | 2:28 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V003_DaytimeAftermathWalkthrough_FullUnit.mov | IMG_4179.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-14 16:31:33-0400) | 540x960 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-004 | Daytime detail walkthrough continuing V-003 (~4 min later). Kitchen counter with books and studio monitor; close-up of water-damaged book on butcher block (partial title visible beginning with "Ma," "Los Angeles Times Book..." text); water staining on butcher block; stove grates; displaced electronics, shoes, cables on floor with blue storage bin; grey sectional sofa; exposed brick wall with aluminum step ladder; close-up of dark surface showing water damage with cable routing. | View | 1:16 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V004_DaytimeDetailWalkthrough_BookDamage.mov | IMG_4182.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-14 16:35:40-0400) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-005 | Day-after walkthrough (~24 hours post-flood). Concrete floor with water staining and residue at wall/floor junction. Furniture casters on wet concrete. Red basin visible (leak catchment). Bookshelf with cables. Persian rug with water saturation at edges where it meets concrete. Metal table leg on stained floor. Bedroom area visible at end with bedding on dark rug. | View | 0:57 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V005_FloorDamageWalkthrough_RugFurniture.mov | IMG_4238.MOV | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-15 17:32:34-0400) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-006 | Wall cavity inspection 2 days post-flood. Exposed 2-foot remediation cut along wall base revealing pink fiberglass insulation (wet/degraded). Metal stud framing and tracks with mineral deposits. Red fire-stop sealant with dark contamination behind it. Sections of wall covered with brown tape/plastic sheeting. Multiple stud bays exposed showing extent of water penetration into wall cavities. Red/brown floor staining. Cross-references WT-113 (Common Hallway 2-Foot Cut). | View | 0:53 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V006_WallCavityInspection_2FootCut.mov | IMG_4255.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-16 15:49:13-0400) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-007 | Brief low-light evening clip 2 days post-flood. White metal frame (folding furniture). Dark concrete floor. White bar stools. Blue container/bag on surface with electronics nearby. Cables on floor. Dark rug visible. Mostly underexposed — limited evidentiary detail due to poor lighting and very brief duration. | View | 0:05 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V007_LowLightInterior_DisplacedFurniture.mp4 | IMG_4257.MOV | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-16 19:11:45-0400) | 1080x1920 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-008 | Close-up mattress damage documentation 3 days post-flood. Quilted mattress with leaf/floral pattern displaced onto floor. Visible water staining/discoloration on fabric surface. Dark burgundy rug beneath also water-damaged. Person's black shoes visible for scale. Forms documentation pair with V-009. | View | 0:12 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V008_MattressDamageCloseUp.mp4 | IMG_4298.MOV | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-17 18:56:02-0400) | 1080x1920 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-009 | Wider mattress documentation continuing V-008 (~1 minute later). Full mattress surface showing quilted pattern with central water stain/discoloration mark. Mattress edge piping showing water exposure. Dark glossy furniture surface visible at end. Dark burgundy rug beneath. Documents total loss condition (cross-references photo seq 153–154 curbside disposal). | View | 0:17 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V009_MattressDamageWideView.mp4 | IMG_4299.MOV | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-17 18:57:04-0400) | 1080x1920 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-010 | Rug damage documentation with water extraction equipment 3 days post-flood. Dark red/burgundy rug with severely degraded/darkened fringe edges. Water stain patterns on rug surface. Concrete floor alongside rug edge showing tide marks. Floor lamp with chrome base. Black corrugated shop vac hose on rug (active extraction effort). White cables displaced on floor. | View | 0:31 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V010_RugDamage_ExtractionEquipment.mov | IMG_4319.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-17 19:22:35-0400) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-011 | Brief midday clip 4 days post-flood. Wooden step stool/bench with potential water staining on surface. Dark grey concrete floor. Items on shelf. Floor/box fan visible (drying/air circulation effort). Significant motion blur due to rapid camera movement and very brief duration. | View | 0:02 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V011_FurnitureDetail_FanDrying.mov | IMG_4372.MOV | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-18 12:43:34-0400) | 1080x1920 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-012 | Sofa/couch water damage inspection 4 days post-flood. Dark grey fabric sectional with visible water staining and tide marks on cushions and back panels. Wet discoloration patterns on fabric surface. Cushion displacement for inspection. Floor lamp base visible. Stained concrete floor beneath furniture. | View | 0:30 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V012_SofaWaterDamageInspection.mov | IMG_4376.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-18 14:12:54-0400) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-013 | Extended sofa water staining documentation continuing V-012 (~48 seconds later). Multiple angles of same dark grey sectional showing water tide marks/staining lines along armrests and cushion backs. Shelving unit with baskets visible in background. White towel/fabric placed on cushions. Detail coverage of fabric degradation from prolonged water exposure. | View | 0:51 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V013_SofaWaterStainingDetail.mov | IMG_4377.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-18 14:13:42-0400) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-014 | Headlamp inspection 10 days post-flood. Person wearing Energizer headlamp and baseball cap inspecting dark unit interior. Wet/contaminated concrete floor with debris and mineral deposits visible. Headlamp required indicates inadequate lighting conditions persisting. Dark/dim conditions throughout with headlamp as primary illumination. | View | 0:49 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V014_HeadlampInspection_FloorDamage.mov | IMG_4446.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-24 11:03:19-0400) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-015 | Respirator inspection with standing water 10 days post-flood. Person wearing 3M-style dual-cartridge respirator and Energizer headlamp. Standing water/dark pooling visible on floor around ProForm 635CW treadmill. Active water still present on concrete floor 10 days after initial flood. Dark conditions requiring headlamp. Continuation of V-014 inspection session (~5 minutes later). | View | 0:37 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V015_RespiratorInspection_StandingWater.mov | IMG_4448.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-24 11:08:27-0400) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-016 | Nighttime loft walkthrough during active flood. Very low-light interior with hanging bare light bulb visible. Boxes and personal items in dim conditions. Cardboard box with papers/documents. General low-light documentation of loft space during or shortly after flood event. Landscape orientation (second-device footage). CROSS-REF: Same recording as WT-116 V-02 (Laurie_SallyG4OffCameraAudio.MOV) — matching timestamp 00:20:11 EDT, duration 0:36, resolution 1280x720, device iPhone 6s. Sherman return copy under iPhone auto-naming. | View | 0:36 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V016_NighttimeLoftWalkthrough_LaurieAudio.mov | IMG_7948.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-14 00:20:11-0400) | 1280x720 (16:9 landscape) | iPhone 6s (iOS 12.1.2) |
| V-017 | Nighttime dialog during active flood. Extremely low-light conditions — nearly indiscernible. Floor-level view with items barely visible. Dark surfaces with faint reflections. Landscape orientation (second-device footage). CROSS-REF: Same recording as WT-116 V-04 (Laurie_DialogAboutSrinklerBreak.MOV) — matching timestamp 00:22:26 EDT, duration 0:21, resolution 1280x720, device iPhone 6s. Sherman return copy under iPhone auto-naming. | View | 0:21 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V017_NighttimeSprinklerDialog.mov | IMG_7950.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-14 00:22:26-0400) | 1280x720 (16:9 landscape) | iPhone 6s (iOS 12.1.2) |
| V-018 | Afternoon walkthrough from dark loft/hallway area to main living space doorway. Bicycle wheel and red container in dark area. Final frame: doorway view showing extensive water staining patterns on concrete floor, red basin (leak catchment), white kitchen cabinets with displaced items. | View | 0:25 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V018_LoftHallwayToUnitDoorway.mp4 | IMG_4180.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; HB date: 2019-10-14 16:34:16-0400) | 1080x720 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-019 | Afternoon equipment and structural inspection. Black electronic equipment case with green LED indicator on water-saturated Persian rug. Close-up of white surface with water stain line. Metal stand/frame legs. Ceiling/wall junction gap inspection. | View | 0:27 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V019_EquipmentRugInspection.mp4 | IMG_4181.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; HB date: 2019-10-14 16:34:52-0400) | 1080x720 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-020 | Day-after standing water documentation. Active standing water pooling on concrete floor at Persian rug edge. Water reflections visible on floor surface. Saturated rug fringe darkened and degraded. Cloth/towel at water-rug boundary as containment attempt. | View | 0:27 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V020_StandingWaterRugEdge.mp4 | IMG_4237.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; HB date: 2019-10-15 17:14:17-0400) | 1060x720 (~9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-021 | Day-after floor-level damage inspection at furniture bases. White round object with cables, T-shaped tool on stained concrete. Wall/furniture junction water damage and debris. White upholstery/fabric viewed from below showing water staining. | View | 0:20 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V021_FloorLevelFurnitureDamage.mp4 | IMG_4239.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; HB date: 2019-10-15 17:34:16-0400) | 1080x720 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-022 | Evening walkthrough 2 days post-flood. Persian rug with floral pattern. Industrial rental dehumidifier (blue Dri-Eaz-style commercial unit with RENTAL label on front panel) on stained concrete floor. Motion blur across butcher block counter. Dark frames with blue LED. Displaced items. | View | 0:37 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V022_IndustrialDehumidifierWalkthrough.mp4 | IMG_4258.mov | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; HB date: 2019-10-16 19:11:56-0400) | 1080x720 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-023 | Close-up mattress and rug water damage documentation 3 days post-flood. Quilted mattress with leaf/floral pattern resting on dark burgundy Persian rug. Rug surface wet and glossy with active moisture reflections visible. Multiple angles showing mattress edge meeting saturated rug. Water pooling on rug surface. | View | 0:19 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V023_MattressRugWaterDamage.mp4 | IMG_4303.MOV | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-17 18:59:37-0400) | 1080x1920 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-024 | Speaker equipment on wet floor 10 days post-flood. Large black PA/studio monitor speaker on water-stained concrete floor with clear wet/dry boundaries and standing water reflections. Multiple angles showing speaker base in standing water. Additional audio equipment stacked with cables visible. Water staining patterns on concrete around equipment. | View | 0:20 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V024_SpeakerEquipmentWetFloor.mp4 | IMG_4447.MOV | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-24 11:05:06-0400) | 1080x1920 (9:16 portrait) | iPhone X (iOS 13.1.2) |
| V-025 | Nighttime loft walkthrough during active flood. Very dark interior with hanging bare bulb light fixture. White structural column. Folding chair. Red glow from equipment/emergency light. Kitchen area with butcher block counter and bar stool visible in final frames. Low-light emergency conditions. CROSS-REF: Same recording as WT-116 V-03 (Laurie_ThisIsCrazy.MOV) — matching timestamp 00:20:51 EDT, duration 0:17, resolution 1920x1080, device iPhone 6s. Sherman return copy under iPhone auto-naming. | View | 0:17 | FLOOD_97GreenStG21_V025_NighttimeLoftWalkthrough.MOV | IMG_7949.MOV | October 2019 (Attorney Sherman; QT: 2019-10-14 00:20:51-0400) | 1920x1080 (16:9 landscape) | iPhone 6s (iOS 12.1.2) |
3.2 Video Technical Metadata¶
| Field | V-001 | V-002 | V-003 | V-004 | V-005 | V-006 | V-007 | V-008 | V-009 | V-010 | V-011 | V-012 | V-013 | V-014 | V-015 | V-016 | V-017 | V-018 | V-019 | V-020 | V-021 | V-022 | V-023 | V-024 | V-025 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Original filename | IMG_4174.mp4 | IMG_4163.mov | IMG_4179.mov | IMG_4182.mov | IMG_4238.MOV | IMG_4255.mov | IMG_4257.MOV | IMG_4298.MOV | IMG_4299.MOV | IMG_4319.mov | IMG_4372.MOV | IMG_4376.mov | IMG_4377.mov | IMG_4446.mov | IMG_4448.mov | IMG_7948.mov | IMG_7950.mov | IMG_4180.mov | IMG_4181.mov | IMG_4237.mov | IMG_4239.mov | IMG_4258.mov | IMG_4303.MOV | IMG_4447.MOV | IMG_7949.MOV |
| Duration | 42.7 seconds | 69.5 seconds | 147.8 seconds | 76.2 seconds | 56.6 seconds | 53.0 seconds | 5.5 seconds | 11.7 seconds | 16.6 seconds | 31.0 seconds | 2.5 seconds | 30.3 seconds | 51.3 seconds | 49.1 seconds | 36.7 seconds | 35.9 seconds | 20.7 seconds | 25.4 seconds | 27.2 seconds | 27.1 seconds | 20.2 seconds | 37.2 seconds | 19.4 seconds | 19.5 seconds | 17.2 seconds |
| File size | 12.31 MB | 11.04 MB | 17.00 MB | 11.75 MB | 9.31 MB | 7.55 MB | 5.21 MB | 10.83 MB | 14.38 MB | 4.96 MB | 2.12 MB | 4.62 MB | 8.08 MB | 7.02 MB | 5.65 MB | 5.64 MB | 3.25 MB | 7.43 MB | 7.91 MB | 7.82 MB | 5.84 MB | 10.69 MB | 17.79 MB | 18.00 MB | 16.60 MB |
| Video codec | H.264 High | H.264 Main | H.264 Main | H.264 Main | H.264 Main | H.264 Main | HEVC Main | HEVC Main | HEVC Main | H.264 Main | HEVC Main | H.264 Main | H.264 Main | H.264 Main | H.264 Main | H.264 Main | H.264 Main | H.264 High | H.264 High | H.264 High | H.264 High | H.264 High | HEVC Main | HEVC Main | H.264 High |
| Resolution | 1080x720 (9:16 portrait) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | 540x960 (9:16 portrait) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | 1080x1920 (9:16 portrait) | 1080x1920 (9:16 portrait) | 1080x1920 (9:16 portrait) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | 1080x1920 (9:16 portrait) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | 720x1280 (9:16 portrait) | 1280x720 (16:9 landscape) | 1280x720 (16:9 landscape) | 1080x720 (9:16 portrait) | 1080x720 (9:16 portrait) | 1060x720 (~9:16 portrait) | 1080x720 (9:16 portrait) | 1080x720 (9:16 portrait) | 1080x1920 (9:16 portrait) | 1080x1920 (9:16 portrait) | 1920x1080 (16:9 landscape) |
| Frame rate | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 29.97 fps | 29.97 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 30 fps | 29.97 fps |
| Audio codec | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz | AAC mono 44.1 kHz |
| Bitrate | ~2.4 Mbps | ~1.3 Mbps | ~965 kbps | ~1.3 Mbps | ~1.3 Mbps | ~1.1 Mbps | ~7.9 Mbps | ~7.7 Mbps | ~7.2 Mbps | ~1.2 Mbps | ~6.9 Mbps | ~1.2 Mbps | ~1.2 Mbps | ~1.1 Mbps | ~1.2 Mbps | ~1.2 Mbps | ~1.2 Mbps | ~2.3 Mbps | ~2.3 Mbps | ~2.2 Mbps | ~2.3 Mbps | ~2.2 Mbps | ~7.7 Mbps | ~7.7 Mbps | ~8.1 Mbps |
| Encoder | HandBrake 1.10.2 | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | HandBrake 1.10.2 | HandBrake 1.10.2 | HandBrake 1.10.2 | HandBrake 1.10.2 | HandBrake 1.10.2 | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) | N/A (native MOV) |
| QT creationdate | N/A (re-encoded) | 2019-10-14 00:19:39-0400 | 2019-10-14 16:31:33-0400 | 2019-10-14 16:35:40-0400 | 2019-10-15 17:32:34-0400 | 2019-10-16 15:49:13-0400 | 2019-10-16 19:11:45-0400 | 2019-10-17 18:56:02-0400 | 2019-10-17 18:57:04-0400 | 2019-10-17 19:22:35-0400 | 2019-10-18 12:43:34-0400 | 2019-10-18 14:12:54-0400 | 2019-10-18 14:13:42-0400 | 2019-10-24 11:03:19-0400 | 2019-10-24 11:08:27-0400 | 2019-10-14 00:20:11-0400 | 2019-10-14 00:22:26-0400 | HB date: 2019-10-14 16:34:16-0400 | HB date: 2019-10-14 16:34:52-0400 | HB date: 2019-10-15 17:14:17-0400 | HB date: 2019-10-15 17:34:16-0400 | HB date: 2019-10-16 19:11:56-0400 | 2019-10-17 18:59:37-0400 | 2019-10-24 11:05:06-0400 | 2019-10-14 00:20:51-0400 |
| Audio review | Mono track present (42.7s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (69.5s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (147.8s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (76.2s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (56.6s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (53.0s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (5.5s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (11.7s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (16.6s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (31.0s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (2.5s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (30.3s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (51.3s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (49.1s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (36.7s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (35.9s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (20.7s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (25.4s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (27.2s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (27.1s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (20.2s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (37.2s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (19.4s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (19.5s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription | Mono track present (17.2s) — flagged for manual listen/transcription |
| Quality | GOOD | GOOD | GOOD | GOOD | GOOD | GOOD | POOR | GOOD | GOOD | GOOD | FAIR | GOOD | GOOD | FAIR | FAIR | POOR | POOR | FAIR | FAIR | FAIR | FAIR | FAIR | GOOD | FAIR | POOR |
| Evidentiary | HIGH | HIGH | HIGH | HIGH | HIGH | HIGH | LOW | HIGH | HIGH | HIGH | MEDIUM | HIGH | HIGH | HIGH | HIGH | MEDIUM | LOW | MEDIUM | MEDIUM | HIGH | MEDIUM | HIGH | HIGH | HIGH | MEDIUM |
| SHA256 | (pre-compression; not retained) | fe9ae7e1...806e390 | f86bea45...75003b | 79711498...db7f857 | 02085d28...e81949 | a53ff272...5ead3a | 67242f40...0e3a24 | 8c44cdf8...8df56e | 95cae195...034ff6 | b3c2ca57...002c702a | ae7ae71d...d3c4e8 | d6bba72d...93ac8d | 1e8f82bc...f81b9a | 130c0c63...e85031 | 306e982d...cc2f94 | 485eb6fc...ebc7e5 | 8becf4d3...67d5ff0 | dc351c31...55a4a6c | 16c6dbec...4b53f9 | dd395468...f7abc6 | 7ac88544...2e715d3 | 45703294...77d54e3 | b115c2a1...d0374e | 42cca979...495c6b | 4310e0ba...923caa |
3.3 Keyframe Contact Sheet¶
V-001: 3x3 grid at 5-second intervals (9 frames)

V-002: 5x3 grid at 5-second intervals (14 frames)

V-003: 6x5 grid at 5-second intervals (30 frames)

V-004: 5x3 grid at 5-second intervals (15 frames)

V-005: 4x3 grid at 5-second intervals (11 frames)

V-006: 4x3 grid at 5-second intervals (11 frames)

V-007: 3x2 grid at 1-second intervals (5 frames; adapted interval for 5-second video)

V-008: 3x2 grid at 2-second intervals (6 frames; adapted interval for 12-second video)

V-009: 3x2 grid at 3-second intervals (6 frames; adapted interval for 17-second video)

V-010: 3x2 grid at 5-second intervals (6 frames)

V-011: 3x2 grid at 0.5-second intervals (5 frames; adapted interval for 2.5-second video)

V-012: 3x2 grid at 5-second intervals (6 frames)

V-013: 4x3 grid at 5-second intervals (10 frames)

V-014: 4x3 grid at 5-second intervals (10 frames)

V-015: 4x2 grid at 5-second intervals (7 frames)

V-016: 4x2 grid at 5-second intervals (7 frames; landscape orientation)

V-017: 2x2 grid at 5-second intervals (4 frames; landscape orientation)

V-018: 3x2 grid at 5-second intervals (5 frames)

V-019: 3x2 grid at 5-second intervals (5 frames)

V-020: 3x2 grid at 5-second intervals (5 frames)

V-021: 2x2 grid at 5-second intervals (4 frames)

V-022: 4x2 grid at 5-second intervals (7 frames)

V-023: 3x2 grid at 3-second intervals (6 frames; adapted interval for 19-second video)

V-024: 4x2 grid at 3-second intervals (7 frames; adapted interval for 20-second video)

V-025: 3x2 grid at 3-second intervals (6 frames; adapted interval for 17-second video)

3.4 Key Evidentiary Observations — Video (facts-only)¶
V-001 — Bedroom Flood Walkthrough:
- 00:00–00:15: Camera pans across bedroom; low-light conditions consistent with emergency/power disruption
- 00:20: Floor surface shows reflective standing water — confirms active flood with measurable depth
- 00:25: Wall/ceiling junction shows radiating water streaks — documents intrusion source point
- 00:25–00:40: Mattress visible with contamination streaking pattern consistent with wicking from standing water contact
- Audio: Mono track present throughout; content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription)
V-002 — Nighttime Loft Walkthrough (00:19:39 EDT):
- 00:00–00:10: Dark interior of loft unit; bottle and items on counter/table visible; red/burgundy furniture
- 00:15–00:20: Camera tilts upward to exposed ceiling infrastructure — white pipes, pipe junctions, and industrial ceiling visible; possible moisture at junction point
- 00:25–00:30: Pendant light fixture visible; butcher block counter surface with items below
- 00:30–00:40: Table/counter surface with papers, items; very low light throughout
- 00:40–00:55: Camera moves through darker areas of unit; storage items, furniture visible
- 00:55–01:09: Wall/ceiling area; cluttered living space overview; person partially visible in final frames
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (69.5s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription)
- CROSS-REF NOTE: QuickTime metadata timestamp (2019-10-14 00:19:39-0400), duration (1:09), resolution (1280x720), and device (iPhone X) match WT-116 V-01 (original: ChristianGrayDocumentation.MOV). Probable same recording received through Attorney Sherman return path under iPhone auto-naming (IMG_4163). Two independent transmission chains corroborate authenticity.
V-003 — Daytime Aftermath Walkthrough (16:31:33 EDT):
- 00:00–00:15: Floor-level view showing wet/stained concrete floor; foot stepping through; furniture base with water damage marks; white furniture base on wet surface
- 00:15–00:25: Persian/oriental rug with extensive water damage and staining visible in daylight; dark water marks throughout pattern
- 00:25–00:40: Furniture base on patterned rug; hardwood/laminate floor with visible water line along baseboard; transition to kitchen area
- 00:40–01:00: Butcher block counter with everyday items (glass bowl with bananas, keyboard); water marks on wood surface
- 01:00–01:15: Bedroom area — blue bedding on blue-upholstered bed frame with red patterned area rug beneath; foot stepping on rug
- 01:15–01:30: Grey sectional sofa with patterned throw/blanket; daylight streaming through windows illuminating full loft space; bookshelf against far wall visible
- 01:30–01:45: Floor area with cables, clothing items, displaced personal items; studio monitor speaker visible on desk/stand (recording equipment)
- 01:45–02:00: Concrete floor with metal table/desk legs; cleaning tool visible
- 02:00–02:28: Darker areas of unit; closing frames
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (147.8s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription)
- UNIQUE VALUE: Only daylight documentation of flood aftermath in Sherman return set. Natural lighting reveals damage detail invisible in nighttime videos. Studio monitor speaker documents recording equipment presence (Freeman Street connection).
V-004 — Daytime Detail Walkthrough (16:35:40 EDT):
- 00:00–00:10: Kitchen area with studio monitor speaker and stacked books on butcher block counter; white cabinet drawers below
- 00:10–00:15: Close-up of water-damaged book on butcher block — cover shows partial title beginning with "Ma" and text reading "Los Angeles Times Book..." visible; book pages severely warped/swollen from water exposure; hand holding book
- 00:15–00:25: Butcher block surface close-up showing wood grain and water staining; gas stove burner grates visible with sunlight
- 00:25–00:40: Interior overview — displaced items including electronics/bags; pink/magenta storage container; scattered items on floor
- 00:35–00:45: Floor area with multiple shoes/sneakers scattered; blue storage bin; cables/cords on concrete floor; desk/table legs
- 00:45–00:55: Grey sectional sofa with light-colored towel/fabric draped on cushion
- 00:50–01:05: Exposed brick wall area with aluminum step ladder; hand gesturing; pink yoga mat; concrete floor with staining
- 01:05–01:16: Close-up of dark reflective surface (possibly recording equipment or furniture) showing water damage patterns; cable routing visible along brick wall
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (76.2s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription)
- UNIQUE VALUE: Water-damaged book close-up with partial title identification. Displaced personal items detail. Continuation of V-003 afternoon documentation (~4 minutes later).
V-005 — Day-After Floor Damage Walkthrough (17:32:34 EDT, October 15):
- 00:00–00:10: Camera focused on concrete floor at wall/floor base junction; water staining and residue visible; furniture caster/foot on wet surface
- 00:10–00:20: Continues along floor base showing water damage line; red basin visible (positioned to catch ongoing drips — active leak management)
- 00:20–00:30: Bookshelf with cables visible; transition across floor
- 00:30–00:40: Persian rug edge meeting stained concrete; water saturation visible at textile/concrete boundary; metal table/stand leg on wet surface
- 00:40–00:50: Motion across rug surface showing water damage patterns; furniture legs visible
- 00:50–00:57: Bedroom area — bed with light bedding visible on dark rug/carpet
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (56.6s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription)
- UNIQUE VALUE: First documentation from the day after the flood (Oct 15). Red basin confirms ongoing leak/drip issues ~24 hours later. Shows residual water damage state before any cleanup intervention.
V-006 — Wall Cavity Inspection / 2-Foot Cut (15:49:13 EDT, October 16):
- 00:00–00:10: Close-up of exposed wall cavity — pink fiberglass insulation (wet/degraded) above, concrete/plaster wall surface below with pitting and mineral deposits, metal track at base with debris
- 00:10–00:20: Additional wall cavity angle showing metal stud framing with screws; insulation pulled away from wall surface
- 00:20–00:25: Red fire-stop sealant visible at stud junction; dark contamination visible behind/below sealant on wall cavity surface
- 00:25–00:30: Motion through dark corridor/hallway area
- 00:30–00:40: Wall sections with brown tape/plastic sheeting covering lower portion (remediation barrier over 2-foot cut opening)
- 00:40–00:50: Hallway perspective showing extent of wall cut; pink insulation visible through multiple openings below cut line
- 00:50–00:53: Close-up of cut edge showing exposed stud bays with contaminated insulation; red/brown floor staining
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (53.0s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription)
- UNIQUE VALUE: Documents remediation 2-foot cut with exposed wall cavities showing contaminated insulation, fire-stop sealant with dark contamination, and metal framing damage. Cross-references WT-113 (Common Hallway 2-Foot Cut). Critical evidence for scope manipulation documentation.
V-007 — Low-Light Interior / Displaced Furniture (19:11:45 EDT, October 16):
- 00:00–00:02: Dark frame with white metal frame (folding furniture/rack) and cables visible on floor
- 00:02–00:04: Motion across dark floor; furniture forms barely visible
- 00:04–00:05: White bar stools, blue container/bag on surface, electronics nearby; dark rug visible
- Audio: Mono track present (5.5s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription)
- LIMITATION: Very brief duration (5 seconds) and severely underexposed. Limited evidentiary detail recoverable. Documents displaced furniture in evening lighting 2 days post-flood.
V-008 — Mattress Damage Close-Up (18:56:02 EDT, October 17):
- 00:00–00:04: Close-up of quilted mattress surface (leaf/floral pattern) displaced directly onto floor; water staining/discoloration visible on fabric; dark burgundy rug beneath
- 00:04–00:08: Camera moves along mattress edge; person's black shoes visible providing scale reference; mattress appears directly on floor (removed from frame)
- 00:08–00:12: Continued mattress surface documentation; shadow of documenter visible on rug; dark fabric/clothing in background
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (11.7s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription)
- UNIQUE VALUE: First close-up documentation of mattress contamination. Forms documentation pair with V-009. Mattress displacement onto contaminated rug confirms total loss condition.
V-009 — Mattress Damage Wide View (18:57:04 EDT, October 17):
- 00:00–00:06: Wider angle of same mattress showing full edge and corner; quilted pattern with visible staining; person's shoes for scale
- 00:06–00:10: Full mattress surface view showing extent of water damage; central stain/discoloration mark clearly visible
- 00:10–00:14: Continued surface documentation; mattress edge piping visible showing water exposure
- 00:14–00:17: Pan to end of mattress; dark glossy surface visible (furniture piece)
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (16.6s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription)
- UNIQUE VALUE: Wider perspective complementing V-008 close-up. Central water stain documented. Cross-references photo seq 153–154 (curbside mattress/furniture disposal — total loss outcome).
V-010 — Rug Damage with Extraction Equipment (19:22:35 EDT, October 17):
- 00:00–00:10: Dark red/burgundy rug edge with severely degraded/darkened fringe; clear tube/pipe along rug-concrete boundary; floor lamp chrome base visible; white cables
- 00:10–00:15: Black corrugated shop vac hose on rug surface — documents active water extraction effort 3 days post-flood
- 00:15–00:25: Concrete floor alongside rug edge showing water tide marks; rug surface with dark water stain patterns visible
- 00:25–00:31: Continued rug documentation; displaced cables; lamp base
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (31.0s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription)
- UNIQUE VALUE: Documents active water extraction equipment presence 3 days post-flood (shop vac hose). Rug fringe degradation shows textile damage from prolonged water exposure. Tide marks on concrete adjacent to rug establish water extent.
V-011 — Furniture Detail with Fan / Drying Effort (12:43:34 EDT, October 18):
- 00:00–00:01: Wooden step stool/bench on grey concrete floor with potential water staining on wood surface; items on white shelf above
- 00:01–00:02: Floor/box fan visible (drying/air circulation effort); rapid camera movement producing motion blur
- Audio: Mono track present (2.5s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription)
- LIMITATION: Very brief duration (2.5 seconds) with significant motion blur. Confirms ongoing drying effort 4 days post-flood (fan present) and continued displacement conditions.
V-012 — Sofa Water Damage Inspection (14:12:54 EDT, October 18):
- 00:00–00:10: Close-up of dark grey fabric sectional sofa. Back cushion and armrest visible with water staining/tide marks — clear discoloration line across fabric. Cushion pulled away from base showing wet area beneath. Small items on furniture shelf above.
- 00:10–00:20: Moves along sofa backrest showing water staining pattern continuing across full length. Fabric texture shows wet-dry boundary line. Floor visible beneath showing stained concrete.
- 00:20–00:30: Floor lamp base visible adjacent to sofa. Additional staining visible on cushion backs from different angle. Sofa moved from original position for inspection.
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (30.3s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription)
- UNIQUE VALUE: First detailed furniture damage documentation. Water tide marks on fabric demonstrate prolonged water contact at specific depth. Pairs with V-013 for comprehensive sofa documentation.
V-013 — Sofa Water Staining Detail (14:13:42 EDT, October 18):
- 00:00–00:10: Continuation of sofa inspection. Dark grey sectional shown from different angle. Water staining visible as lighter discoloration lines along fabric back and armrest. Partially visible sofa base with wet concrete floor beneath.
- 00:10–00:20: Close-up of armrest showing water tide line — clear boundary between soaked and dry fabric sections. Staining consistent with wicking from standing water contact.
- 00:20–00:30: Camera moves along sofa toward wall side. Shelving unit visible in background with wicker basket. Throw blanket/towel visible on cushion (likely placed for absorption).
- 00:30–00:40: Continued inspection showing back of sofa against wall. Water staining visible at consistent height across multiple cushion sections.
- 00:40–00:51: Final angles showing full extent of water damage; sofa corner and end section visible. Shelving unit with stacked items.
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (51.3s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription)
- UNIQUE VALUE: Extended documentation complementing V-012. Multiple angles establish water damage at consistent height across entire sofa length — demonstrates uniform flood depth at furniture location. Longest single-item damage documentation in video set.
V-014 — Headlamp Inspection / Floor Damage (11:03:19 EDT, October 24):
- 00:00–00:10: Selfie-angle view of person wearing Energizer-brand headlamp (green band) over baseball cap. Headlamp illuminated. Dark interior visible behind.
- 00:10–00:15: Person adjusting position; looking downward. Headlamp provides primary illumination — ambient light very limited.
- 00:15–00:25: Camera transitions to floor-level. Wet/contaminated concrete floor visible with debris, mineral deposits, and dark staining. Cable or thin object on floor surface.
- 00:25–00:35: Very dark — person's clothing/body partially visible. Headlamp beam creates small illuminated area on surfaces.
- 00:35–00:49: Floor inspection continues in very dim conditions. Extension cord or cable visible. Dark wet surfaces. Concrete floor with residue.
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (49.1s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription — potentially significant as inspection narration)
- UNIQUE VALUE: Documents conditions 10 days post-flood — unit still requires headlamp for illumination and shows wet/contaminated surfaces. Establishes ongoing uninhabitable conditions well beyond initial flood event. First video from Oct 24 recording window.
V-015 — Respirator Inspection / Standing Water (11:08:27 EDT, October 24):
- 00:00–00:05: Ceiling/overhead view transitioning to selfie angle. Person wearing 3M-style dual-cartridge half-face respirator and Energizer headlamp. Same individual as V-014.
- 00:05–00:10: Full-face selfie showing respirator with dual organic vapor cartridges. Headlamp illuminated. Dark clothing. Background shows ceiling and upper wall area of unit.
- 00:10–00:20: Camera pans down to floor. ProForm 635CW treadmill visible (exercise equipment). Standing water/dark pooling visible on concrete floor around and beneath treadmill base. Active water reflection visible.
- 00:20–00:30: ProForm 635CW close-up — equipment sitting in standing water. Floor surface shows dark pooling extending across visible area. Wall baseboard area visible.
- 00:30–00:37: Additional floor angles showing water-damaged concrete surface. Standing water still present. ProForm equipment visible with water reflection.
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (36.7s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription — potentially significant as inspection narration with respirator use)
- UNIQUE VALUE: Documents standing water AND respirator use 10 days post-flood — dual evidence of ongoing habitability hazard (water + air quality requiring respiratory protection). ProForm 635CW treadmill documents specific personal property in standing water. Most significant evidence of prolonged uninhabitable conditions in video set.
V-016 — Nighttime Loft Walkthrough / Laurie Audio (00:20:11 EDT, October 14):
- 00:00–00:10: Very dark loft interior. Hanging bare light bulb visible in upper frame — only artificial light source. Counter/surface with items barely visible below.
- 00:10–00:15: Camera pans across dark space. Bedding/fabric and boxes visible in extremely low light. Some items on elevated surfaces.
- 00:15–00:20: Cardboard box with papers/documents visible. Small items on surfaces. Very limited detail recoverable due to darkness.
- 00:20–00:30: Camera moves through dark areas. Light bulb swings into frame again showing ceiling area. Wall and doorway/corridor visible.
- 00:30–00:36: Additional dark interior frames. Hanging light bulb. Items on shelves barely discernible.
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (35.9s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription — WT-116 identifies this as "SallyG4OffCameraAudio" suggesting off-camera dialog)
- CROSS-REF NOTE: QuickTime metadata timestamp (2019-10-14 00:20:11-0400), duration (0:36), resolution (1280x720), and device (iPhone 6s) match WT-116 V-02 (original: Laurie_SallyG4OffCameraAudio.MOV). Same recording received through Attorney Sherman return path under iPhone auto-naming (IMG_7948). Two independent transmission chains corroborate authenticity. Landscape orientation confirms second-device (iPhone 6s) footage concurrent with iPhone X recordings (V-002).
- LIMITATION: Severe underexposure limits visual evidentiary value. Audio track potentially more valuable (dialog content flagged for review).
V-017 — Nighttime Sprinkler Dialog (00:22:26 EDT, October 14):
- 00:00–00:05: Extremely dark frame. Blue/dark object visible (vase or container). Floor surface barely visible with slight reflections suggesting wet surface.
- 00:05–00:10: Continued dark frames. Boxes or items on floor barely discernible. Slight camera movement.
- 00:10–00:15: Similar dark conditions. Objects on floor with faint highlights. No meaningful visual detail recoverable.
- 00:15–00:21: Dark frames continuing. Faint reflections on floor surface.
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (20.7s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual transcription — WT-116 identifies this as "DialogAboutSrinklerBreak" suggesting discussion of sprinkler break cause)
- CROSS-REF NOTE: QuickTime metadata timestamp (2019-10-14 00:22:26-0400), duration (0:21), resolution (1280x720), and device (iPhone 6s) match WT-116 V-04 (original: Laurie_DialogAboutSrinklerBreak.MOV). Same recording received through Attorney Sherman return path under iPhone auto-naming (IMG_7950). Two independent transmission chains corroborate authenticity.
- LIMITATION: Nearly indiscernible visual content. Primary evidentiary value likely in audio track — original filename "DialogAboutSrinklerBreak" indicates contemporaneous discussion of flood cause. Audio transcription priority: HIGH.
V-018 — Loft/Hallway to Unit Doorway (16:34:16 EDT, October 14):
- 00:00–00:05: Dark interior. Red container and light-colored structural elements (wooden chair/stand legs) visible on floor. Low-light conditions.
- 00:05–00:10: Very dark. Barely discernible shapes and surfaces.
- 00:10–00:15: Bicycle wheel visible stored against wall in dark area. Metal spokes and rim. Floor shows water staining.
- 00:15–00:20: Rapid camera movement. Motion blur. Dark interior.
- 00:20–00:25: Doorway view into main living space. Extensive water staining patterns on concrete floor (circular marks from container placement). Red basin visible at doorway edge (leak catchment). White kitchen cabinets with displaced items. Folding chair/stool. Exposed brick wall visible in background.
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (25.4s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual listen/transcription).
- CONTEXT: Captured between V-003 (16:31:33) and V-004 (16:35:40) during afternoon aftermath survey, ~16 hours post-flood.
- HandBrake compressed: Original date preserved via HB date tag. Encoder: HandBrake 1.10.2.
V-019 — Equipment and Rug Inspection (16:34:52 EDT, October 14):
- 00:00–00:05: Black electronic equipment case with green LED indicator light on water-saturated Persian rug. Metal stand/frame legs (aluminum) visible. Rug edge shows water saturation at transition to floor.
- 00:05–00:10: Close-up of white surface with visible crack or water stain line running across it. Possible wall or ceiling damage.
- 00:10–00:15: Additional view of dark electronic equipment with green LED indicators on Persian rug. Metal stand legs.
- 00:15–00:20: Upward view showing ceiling/wall junction with visible gap or separation. Wooden slats (bed frame or shelving) at bottom of frame.
- 00:20–00:27: Close-up of white curved surface (appliance, wall corner, or structural element). Bright/overexposed.
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (27.2s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual listen/transcription).
- CONTEXT: Captured 36 seconds after V-018, between V-018 and V-004 during afternoon session. Electronic equipment on water-damaged rug may have Freeman Street recording connection.
- HandBrake compressed: Original date preserved via HB date tag. Encoder: HandBrake 1.10.2.
V-020 — Standing Water at Rug Edge (17:14:17 EDT, October 15):
- 00:00–00:05: Close-up of standing water on concrete floor at rug boundary. White object (container/cloth) partially in water at rug edge. Dark red/burgundy Persian rug visible.
- 00:05–00:10: Active standing water with visible ceiling/light reflections on water surface. Rug fringe completely saturated and darkened. Water pooling across concrete floor.
- 00:10–00:15: Continued standing water documentation at rug edge. Cloth/towel at boundary appears to be containment attempt.
- 00:15–00:20: Similar angle showing water at rug boundary. Saturated rug fringe with degradation visible.
- 00:20–00:27: Continued documentation of standing water at rug edge. Dark red rug with damaged/saturated fringe.
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (27.1s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual listen/transcription).
- CONTEXT: Day-after documentation (24+ hours post-flood). Captured 18 minutes before V-005 (17:32:34), extending the October 15 documentation window. Standing water still present on Day 2 demonstrates ongoing flooding condition.
- HandBrake compressed: Original date preserved via HB date tag. Encoder: HandBrake 1.10.2. Resolution 1060x720 (HandBrake encoding artifact; display ~9:16 portrait).
V-021 — Floor-Level Furniture Damage (17:34:16 EDT, October 15):
- 00:00–00:05: Looking down at white round object (lamp shade or container) with cables/cords on top. Water-stained concrete floor with debris visible. White rectangular item (cushion/padding) nearby.
- 00:05–00:10: Floor at wall/furniture junction. Black T-shaped tool or nozzle on wet concrete floor. Significant staining and moisture on concrete surface. White furniture piece at edge.
- 00:10–00:15: Similar angle showing T-shaped tool on stained concrete. Bright light source visible. Wooden furniture/shelf edge. Floor debris.
- 00:15–00:20: Upward view showing white fabric/upholstery surface (sofa underside or cushion). Fabric appears water-stained or discolored. Dark staining at edges.
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (20.2s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual listen/transcription).
- CONTEXT: Captured 2 minutes after V-005 (17:32:34) during October 15 day-after session. Floor-level perspective at furniture bases documents water damage pattern at ground level.
- HandBrake compressed: Original date preserved via HB date tag. Encoder: HandBrake 1.10.2.
V-022 — Industrial Dehumidifier Walkthrough (19:11:56 EDT, October 16):
- 00:00–00:05: Persian/oriental rug with detailed red/blue floral pattern clearly visible. White plate/dish on floor. Rug appears wet/saturated.
- 00:05–00:10: Industrial rental dehumidifier: blue Dri-Eaz-style commercial unit with "RENTAL" label on front panel, black metal handle/rack on top, front grille/mesh panel. Sitting on stained concrete floor. Professional-grade water damage restoration equipment.
- 00:10–00:15: Motion blur across butcher block countertop surface. Dark clothing/fabric above counter.
- 00:15–00:20: Dark frame with blue LED indicator light visible (electronic equipment). Very low light.
- 00:20–00:25: Nearly dark frame. White fabric/clothing visible at bottom edge.
- 00:25–00:30: Very dark frame. Minimal discernible detail.
- 00:30–00:37: Blurry frame showing displaced household items: boxes, containers, miscellaneous possessions.
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (37.2s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual listen/transcription).
- CONTEXT: Captured 11 seconds after V-007 (19:11:45), forming a back-to-back pair in the October 16 evening window. Industrial rental dehumidifier documents severity of flood damage (required professional-grade equipment) and tenant's active mitigation effort and cost. Cross-references photo seq 101 (dehumidifier visible in full-unit view).
- HandBrake compressed: Original date preserved via HB date tag. Encoder: HandBrake 1.10.2.
V-023 — Mattress and Rug Water Damage (18:59:37 EDT, October 17):
- 00:00–00:03: Close-up of quilted mattress surface with leaf/floral pattern. Mattress edge resting on dark burgundy Persian rug. Rug surface shows wet sheen with moisture reflections.
- 00:03–00:06: Camera moves along mattress-rug junction. Water visible on rug surface with light reflections showing active moisture. Quilted pattern shows same mattress documented in V-008/V-009.
- 00:06–00:09: Mattress piping/edge detail against wet rug. Rug surface glossy with water. Dark/low-light conditions.
- 00:09–00:12: Continued mattress edge view. Rug moisture reflections prominent with rippled water pattern visible at bottom of frame.
- 00:12–00:15: Quilted mattress surface close-up. Small light-colored item (paper/card) on mattress. Rug surface still showing moisture.
- 00:15–00:19: Wider view of quilted mattress surface with water-glossy rug visible at bottom. Dark objects visible at frame edges.
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (19.4s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual listen/transcription).
- CONTEXT: Captured 2 minutes 33 seconds after V-009 (18:57:04) and 23 minutes before V-010 (19:22:35) during October 17 evening damage session. Forms documentation trio with V-008/V-009 showing mattress damage from multiple angles and distances. HEVC codec (1920x1080) — highest native resolution of the mattress documentation set.
- UNIQUE VALUE: Close-up mattress-rug junction detail at higher resolution than V-008/V-009 (1920x1080 vs 1080x1920). Wet rug surface with active moisture reflections directly beneath mattress documents water wicking pathway. Cross-references V-008/V-009 (mattress damage pair) and seq 153-154 (curbside mattress disposal).
V-024 — Speaker Equipment on Wet Floor (11:05:06 EDT, October 24):
- 00:00–00:03: Standing water on concrete floor with light reflections. Black speaker/equipment base visible at frame edge. Clear wet/dry boundary on concrete surface.
- 00:03–00:06: Large black PA/studio monitor speaker on wet concrete floor. Rounded top with speaker grille/horn visible. Brand text visible on top panel. Water staining extends beyond equipment base.
- 00:06–00:09: Speaker viewed from different angle showing mesh grille detail and rounded speaker profile. Water staining patterns on concrete around base. Dark wet zone clearly delineated.
- 00:09–00:12: Water staining on concrete floor with equipment shadow. Wet/dry boundary line clearly visible on concrete surface.
- 00:12–00:15: Floor staining detail showing wet zone patterns on concrete. Equipment base edge visible.
- 00:15–00:18: Full speaker body visible — trapezoidal/wedge-shaped professional monitor with driver cone and handle. Sitting on stained concrete floor. Brand/logo visible on front panel.
- 00:18–00:20: Multiple pieces of black audio equipment stacked/stored together. Handles, speaker cones, and coiled cables visible. Professional audio equipment cluster on wet concrete.
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (19.5s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual listen/transcription).
- CONTEXT: Captured between V-014 (11:03:19, headlamp inspection) and V-015 (11:08:27, respirator + standing water) during October 24 morning session — fills the gap in the Day 10 documentation sequence. Phone held in inverted portrait orientation (+90 rotation vs typical -90).
- UNIQUE VALUE: Documents professional audio/studio equipment sitting in standing water at Day 10 post-flood. PA/studio monitor speakers are professional recording equipment with direct Freeman Street connection. Standing water visible around equipment base reinforces V-015 evidence of ongoing flooding at Day 10. Cross-references V-003 (studio monitor visible in daylight walkthrough) and V-019 (electronic equipment on damaged rug).
V-025 — Nighttime Loft Walkthrough (00:20:51 EDT, October 14):
- 00:00–00:03: Very dark interior. White structural column at center. Hanging bare light bulb fixture visible at left. Dark shapes of furniture/boxes.
- 00:03–00:06: Extremely dark. Faint outlines of doorway/partition and stored items. Minimal discernible detail.
- 00:06–00:09: Hanging bare light bulb fixture glowing against dark interior. Folding metal chair visible below. Dark shapes of displaced items.
- 00:09–00:12: Bare light bulb hanging from cord. Red/warm glow visible at left (equipment LED or emergency light). Boxes and personal items in dim conditions. Floor surface faintly visible.
- 00:12–00:15: Very dark. Red glow from equipment. Faint reflections on surfaces. Kitchen area barely discernible.
- 00:15–00:17: Kitchen area visible: butcher block counter surface, dark equipment (possibly studio-related), bar stool, bright point light source. Most detail-rich frame due to brief camera stabilization.
- Audio: Mono track present throughout (17.2s); content not yet reviewed (flagged for manual listen/transcription). WT-116 original filename "Laurie_ThisIsCrazy.MOV" indicates emotional reaction to flood conditions — audio transcription potentially valuable.
- CONTEXT: Captured at 00:20:51 EDT during active nighttime flood. Timestamp places this 1 minute 12 seconds after V-002 (00:19:39), 40 seconds after V-016 (00:20:11), and 1 minute 35 seconds before V-017 (00:22:26). Third device in the 00:19–00:22 recording cluster.
- WT-116 CROSS-REFERENCE: Same recording as WT-116 V-03 (Laurie_ThisIsCrazy.MOV). Timestamp match: 00:20:51 exact. Duration match: 17.2s vs 17s. Resolution match: 1920x1080. Device match: iPhone 6s. Per Option A: kept with cross-reference notation. Fourth confirmed WT-116 overlap in Sherman return set.
- UNIQUE VALUE: First 1920x1080 iPhone 6s video in Sherman return set — confirms iPhone 6s used multiple resolution settings (1280x720 for V-016/V-017 vs 1920x1080 here). H.264 High profile (vs Main for V-016/V-017). Higher resolution provides slightly more detail than V-016/V-017 in similar lighting conditions.
Section 4: Key Evidentiary Observations — Photos (facts-only)¶
4.1 Temporal Verification¶
| Seq | Evidence | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| 001 | Eagles concert poster: 'Tickets on Sale Friday, October 18' | Independent date verification — October 2019 |
| 026 | Pumpkin visible in frame | Seasonal confirmation — autumn 2019 |
4.2 Flood Depth Quantification¶
| Seq | Evidence | Measurement |
|---|---|---|
| 008 | Tape measure on concrete floor | ~4 inches standing water |
| 009 | Tape measure over submerged rug | ~5 inches standing water |
| 033 | Flood height visible on surfaces | Water line marker |
| 041 | Flood height visible on surfaces | Water line marker |
| 043 | Flood height visible on curtain | Water line / wicking height |
| 074 | Flood height on hallway insulation | Water line marker |
| 125 | Tide line on decorative lighting | Water height indicator |
| V-001 (00:20) | Reflective floor surface | Standing water — active flood |
4.3 Safety Hazards¶
| Seq | Evidence |
|---|---|
| 028 | Electrical cables submerged in standing water |
| 036 | Cables/electronics in flood water — electrocution risk |
| 037 | Additional cables in flood water |
4.4 Defendant Identification¶
| Seq | Evidence |
|---|---|
| 071 | APCO (American Package Co.) mailbox — premises ownership confirmation |
4.5 Bad Faith Contrast — Differential Treatment¶
| Seq | Area | Treatment |
|---|---|---|
| 070–076 | Common hallway | Immediate landlord remediation (2-foot drywall cut, wet insulation removal) |
| 127 | Common hallway | Continued remediation work visible |
| 077–081 | Unit G21 interior | No comparable remediation performed |
4.6 Displacement Evidence¶
| Seq | Evidence |
|---|---|
| 003/013 | Air mattress — sleeping displacement due to flood |
| 133 | Stripped MALM bed frame — bedroom unusable |
| 148 | Bedroom panoramic — complete displacement documentation |
| 153–154 | Curbside disposal of furniture and mattress — forced total loss |
4.7 Mold Contamination¶
| Seq Range | Item | Condition |
|---|---|---|
| 002 | Pipe fitting / ceiling junction | Extensive mold growth pattern |
| 076 | Behind-wall exposure | Mold evidence in wall cavity |
| 084–092 | Bedding, comforters, sheets | Severe mold colonization — total loss |
| 095, 117–120 | Pillows | Water penetration with mold growth |
| 100–105 | Curtain panels | Contamination in folds, biological growth |
| 110, 119–120 | Mattress surfaces | Mold contamination — health hazard |
| 126 | Books | Mold on page edges |
| 145, 147 | MALM drawer interiors | Mineral deposits, mold-consistent spots |
4.8 Brand Documentation (Damages Valuation)¶
| Seq | Brand | Item | Valuation Connection |
|---|---|---|---|
| 064–067 | Stanton Rug Company | Handcrafted area rug | Tab 101 — Property Damage |
| 086 | Beautyrest | Mattress pad | Tab 101 — Property Damage |
| 106–107 | IKEA SULTAN HULTSVIK | Mattress | Tab 101 — Property Damage |
| 108–109 | Sleepy's / Kingsdown Inc. | Mattress (date code ~2000) | Tab 101 — Property Damage |
| 117 | IKEA | Pillow (green label) | Tab 101 — Property Damage |
| 123 | Ralph Lauren | Duvet cover (100% cotton/polyester fill) | Tab 101 — Property Damage |
| 133–135, 139–148 | IKEA MALM | Bed frame + 2 nightstands | Tab 100 / Tab 101 |
| 149–150 | IKEA BILLY | Bookshelf | Tab 101 — Property Damage |
| 101, 140–141, 146 | Dri-Eaz | Dehumidifier (mitigation equipment) | Tab 101.7 — Mitigation |
| 155 | Brooklyn Industries | Jacket | Tab 101.6 — Clothes |
4.9 Freeman Street Equipment Connections¶
| Seq | Evidence | Connection |
|---|---|---|
| 044–045 | Studio equipment in flood area | Freeman Street income documentation |
| 052 | Guitar case in flood water | Instrument damage |
| 068–069 | Musical equipment / cases | Freeman Street losses |
| 080 | Equipment on damaged surfaces | Studio inventory |
| 125 | Guitar case in frame (tide line shot) | Freeman Street connection |
| 152 | Studio monitor speaker visible (wide angle) | Freeman Street connection |
4.10 Tab 100 Before/After Pairings¶
| Tab 100A (Post-Flood) | Tab 100 (Pre-Flood Baseline) | Item |
|---|---|---|
| 005 — MALM dresser in flood water | Tab100_05 — MALM Dresser with Mirror | IKEA MALM 6-drawer dresser |
| 007 — MALM nightstands in water | Tab100_03 — MALM Nightstands | IKEA MALM nightstand pair |
| 133–135, 139–148 — Disassembled/damaged MALM | Tab 100 baseline set | Complete bedroom furniture set |
4.11 Collectible / High-Value Item Loss¶
| Seq | Item | Condition |
|---|---|---|
| 126 | 'Facing Love Addiction' (Pia Mellody); Wilkerson Pulitzer winner (likely 'The Warmth of Other Suns') | Mold on page edges — total loss |
| 150 | 'Master Handbook' (likely 'Master Handbook of Acoustics' — F. Alton Everest); recording/audio reference books | Water damage |
| 156 | 'The Americana' antique encyclopedia set (8+ leather-bound volumes, gold lettering); 'Buckminster Fuller: At Home in the Universe' (Hugh Kenner) | Severe water warping, staining, mold on bindings — collectible total loss |
Section 5: Archive Statistics¶
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Total photos | 156 |
| Total videos | 25 (V-001 through V-025) — COMPLETE |
| Photo batches processed | 15 |
| Photo quality | 153 GOOD (98.1%) / 3 POOR (1.9%) |
| POOR photos | seq 003, 009, 048 (archived; low-light/blur) |
| Photo evidentiary | 103 HIGH / 46 MEDIUM / 7 LOW |
| Brands documented | 10 |
| Active series | 19 |
| Chain of custody | iPhone → Attorney Sherman (Oct 2019) → Returned copies |
| EXIF / metadata status | Photos: EXIF stripped during transmission. Videos: 24 of 25 carry preserved date/time metadata (QT creation dates or HandBrake date tags) |
| Authentication | STRONG — preserved video timestamps (Oct 14–24, 2019), third-party contemporaneous receipt, insurance date of loss corroboration |
5.1 Series Tracking¶
| Series | Photos | Key Seq Numbers |
|---|---|---|
| Curtain Wicking | 9 | 043, 057, 059, 100–105 |
| Mold Contamination | 12 | 076, 084–092, 110, 119–120, 126 |
| Hallway Remediation | 8 | 070–076, 127 |
| Mattress Documentation | 7 | 086, 106–110 |
| Pillow Contamination | 5 | 095, 117–120 |
| Furniture Base Wicking | 6 | 128–132, 136 |
| MALM Bed Frame | 5 | 133, 139–141, 148 |
| MALM Nightstand | 7 | 134–135, 143–147 |
| Bedroom Floor/Walls | 3 | 137–138, 142 |
| Bookshelf / BILLY | 2 | 149–150 |
| Dehumidifier | 4 | 101, 140–141, 146 |
| Tab 100 MALM Connections | 20+ | 005, 007, 012, 016, 039, 081–083, 106–107, 117, 133–135, 139–141, 143–144, 146, 148 |
| Freeman Equipment | 7+ | 044–045, 052, 068–069, 080, 125, 152 |
| Persian Rug | 3 | 040, 111–112 |
| Ralph Lauren Duvet | 3 | 121–123 |
| Butcher Block Damage | 2 | 021, 124 |
| Closet Penetration | 3 | 046, 063, 114 |
| Sectional Sofa | 2 | 151–152 |
| Curbside Disposal | 2 | 153–154 |
Section 6: Cross-Reference Matrix¶
6.1 Internal Cross-References¶
| This Document | Related Document | Relationship |
|---|---|---|
| Photo seq 005, 007, 133–148 | Tab 100 — Pre-Flood Condition Baseline | Before/after furniture pairing |
| All photos | Tab 101 — Property Damage Overview | Visual evidence supporting damage claims |
| Brand documentation (10 brands) | Tab 101 sub-tabs (101.1–101.8) | Replacement valuation by category |
| Flood extent photos | Tab 102 — Business Income Losses | Studio destruction documentation |
| Water depth photos | Tab 103 — Alternative Housing Costs | Uninhabitability evidence |
| Freeman equipment (seq 044–045, 052, 068–069, 080, 125, 152) | Red Volume 06 — Freeman Street | Studio/equipment damage |
6.2 White Volume 07 Cross-References¶
| Tab 100A Content | White Vol 07 Tab | Relationship |
|---|---|---|
| Hallway remediation (seq 070–076, 127) | WT-113 — Common Hallway 2-Foot Cut | Same flood event, differential treatment |
| Seq 127 | WT-113 | Potential scene overlap (different photo file) |
| All October 2019 media | WT-116 — G21 Leaks Documentation | Broader leak pattern context |
| No overlaps confirmed | WT-106A — SERVPRO Field Incident Video | July 2023 event — different devices, different files |
| No overlaps confirmed | WT-111 — July 2023 Re-Flood Email Packet | July 2023 event — different documentation |
Document Control¶
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Document ID | BT-100A |
| Version | 1.2 |
| Status | COMPLETE — Photo archive (156) and video archive (25) finalized |
| Created | 2026-02-01 |
| Last Updated | 2026-03-24 |
| Photos | 156 (15 batches) |
| Videos | 25 (V-001 through V-025) — COMPLETE |
| Prior Version | v1.1.2 (Section 1 authentication predated full video archive) |
Version History¶
| Version | Date | Changes |
|---|---|---|
| v0.1 | 2026-02-01 | Initial draft with Batch 01 (10 photos); Sections 2–9 placeholder |
| v1.0 | 2026-02-01 | Complete rewrite. Integrated all 156 photos across 15 batches into unified WT-116-format table. Added video V-001 with full technical metadata and keyframe contact sheet. Added 11 evidentiary observation subsections. Added series tracking (19 series), brand documentation (10 brands), cross-reference matrix. Replaced batch-by-batch structure with single unified archive. Fixed guardrail to canonical Blue scope statement. Updated photo count from ~200 to 156. Added HD archive note. |
| v1.0.1 | 2026-02-01 | Added videos V-002 (IMG_4163.mov), V-003 (IMG_4179.mov), V-004 (IMG_4182.mov). V-002 is nighttime loft walkthrough with WT-116 V-01 cross-reference (probable same recording via different transmission path). V-003 and V-004 are UNIQUE daytime aftermath walkthroughs (16:31-16:35 EDT, ~16 hours post-flood). Section 3.1 expanded to 4 video rows. Section 3.2 metadata table expanded to 4 columns with SHA256 hashes and QT creation dates. Section 3.3 added 3 contact sheets. Section 3.4 added 3 observation blocks with timestamped descriptions. All three videos are native MOV files with QuickTime metadata preserved (not re-encoded). |
| v1.0.2 | 2026-02-01 | Added videos V-005 through V-011 (7 videos: IMG_4238.MOV, IMG_4255.mov, IMG_4257.MOV, IMG_4298.MOV, IMG_4299.MOV, IMG_4319.mov, IMG_4372.MOV). All UNIQUE — no WT-116 overlap (timestamps Oct 15–18, outside WT-116 nighttime window). 5 new recording windows discovered spanning Oct 15–18. First HEVC (H.265) files in set (V-007, V-008, V-009, V-011 at 1920x1080). V-006 documents wall cavity 2-foot cut with contaminated insulation (cross-refs WT-113). V-008/V-009 form mattress damage documentation pair. V-010 documents water extraction equipment (shop vac) on damaged rug. Section 3.1 expanded to 11 video rows. Section 3.2 expanded to 11 columns. Section 3.3 added 7 contact sheets (adapted grid intervals for short videos). Section 3.4 added 7 observation blocks. Recording windows header updated to reflect Oct 14–18 span. |
| v1.0.3 | 2026-02-01 | Added videos V-012 through V-017 (6 videos: IMG_4376.mov, IMG_4377.mov, IMG_4446.mov, IMG_4448.mov, IMG_7948.mov, IMG_7950.mov). 4 UNIQUE + 2 WT-116 overlaps. V-012/V-013 form sofa water damage documentation pair (Oct 18 afternoon, ~48s apart). V-014/V-015 are Oct 24 recordings — 10 days post-flood — extending documentation span from 4 days to 10 days. V-014 shows headlamp-required conditions; V-015 shows respirator use AND standing water still present at Day 10 (ProForm 635CW treadmill in pooled water). V-016 = WT-116 V-02 (Laurie_SallyG4OffCameraAudio.MOV); V-017 = WT-116 V-04 (Laurie_DialogAboutSrinklerBreak.MOV) — both kept with cross-reference per Option A. First iPhone 6s videos in set (landscape 1280x720, 29.97fps). 2 new recording windows added: Oct 18 afternoon (14:12–14:13 EDT) and Oct 24 morning (11:03–11:08 EDT). Documentation now spans Oct 14–24, 2019 (9 recording windows). Section 3.1 expanded to 17 rows. Section 3.2 expanded to 17 columns. Section 3.3 added 6 contact sheets. Section 3.4 added 6 observation blocks. |
| v1.0.4 | 2026-02-01 | Added videos V-018 through V-022 (5 HandBrake-compressed videos: IMG_4180.mp4, IMG_4181.mp4, IMG_4237.mp4, IMG_4239.mp4, IMG_4258.mp4). All UNIQUE (no WT-116 overlaps). Key discovery: HandBrake preserved original iOS date tag. Industrial rental dehumidifier documented (V-022). Standing water at Day 2 documented (V-020). All H.264 High profile. |
| v1.1 | 2026-02-01 | FINAL VIDEO VERSION. Added videos V-023 through V-025 (3 native MOV files: IMG_4303.MOV, IMG_4447.MOV, IMG_7949.MOV). 2 UNIQUE + 1 WT-116 overlap: V-025 = WT-116 V-03 (Laurie_ThisIsCrazy.MOV) — kept per Option A. V-023 extends Oct 17 mattress documentation (HEVC 1920x1080, forms trio with V-008/V-009). V-024 documents PA/studio speaker equipment in standing water at Day 10 — Freeman Street equipment connection (captured between V-014 and V-015 in Oct 24 session). V-025 is first 1920x1080 iPhone 6s video in Sherman return set — confirms multiple resolution settings on same device (H.264 High vs Main profile). Total: 25 videos (V-001 through V-025), 156 photos. 4 WT-116 overlaps total (V-002=V-01, V-016=V-02, V-017=V-04, V-025=V-03). 9 recording windows spanning Oct 14–24, 2019. All video and photo processing COMPLETE. |
| v1.1.2 | 2026-02-02 | Re-encoded 5 browser-incompatible videos (V-007, V-008, V-009, V-023, V-024) from raw iPhone HEVC .mov/.MOV to HandBrake .mp4. Updated all media links and canonical filenames to reflect .mp4 extension. No content changes. |
| v1.2 | 2026-03-24 | Section 1 authentication framework updated to reflect full 25-video archive. Section 1.2 retitled "Metadata Status" with photo/video distinction (photo EXIF stripped; 24 of 25 videos carry preserved date/time metadata). Section 1.3 restructured from "Three Independent Sources" to "Four Independent Sources" — preserved video timestamps now lead as primary date verification; insurance date of loss added; Eagles poster reference removed. Section 1.4 updated to reference video metadata alongside attorney records. Section 1.6 expanded from V-001-only table to full 25-video summary with device, codec, metadata status, and date span. Section 1.7 HD Archive Note updated to cover native MOV and HandBrake re-encode categories. Section 3 header corrected (V-001 does not carry HandBrake date tag). Chain of custody line updated to "156 photos + 25 videos." Section 5 summary updated with photo/video metadata distinction. No changes to Sections 2, 3, or 4 content. |
| v1.1.1 | 2026-02-01 | Section 3.1 column consistency fix. V-018 through V-025 rows reduced from 12 columns to 9 columns matching V-001–V-017 pattern. Removed inline Overlap Status, Quality, and Evidentiary fields (data retained in Section 3.2 metadata table). Restored [View](media/...) clickable links for V-018–V-025 (previously bare "Interior" text). Moved V-025 WT-116 V-03 cross-reference into Scene Description field matching established CROSS-REF pattern from V-002, V-016, V-017. No content removed — structural normalization only. |
END — Blue Tab 100A — G21 Post-Flood Damage Documentation v1.2