Blue Tab 101.7 — Construction & Emergency Mitigation Evidence¶
GUARDRAIL: BLUE — G21 BASE DAMAGES
G21 flood-related base damages only. No enterprise multipliers, no Freeman Street.
Navigation: ← Return to Tab 101 (Property Damage Overview)
1) Executive Numbers (no interest)¶
| Component | Basis | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Emergency Self‑Help (QM) | 1,700 sq ft × $10/sq ft = $17,000 labor (industry $8–$12; Scott Lieberman/ServiceMaster consult; CPLR 4518 notes) + materials $1,080.27 (18 txns dual‑source) | $18,080.27 |
| Rainbow 2017 (like‑for‑like) | Contractor estimate (pre‑flood configuration) | $312,000.00 |
| Rainbow PAA/Neratoff (alternate) | Modified configuration | $279,894.70 |
| 360 Restoration (specialized) | Mold/water remediation | $122,000.00 |
| Construction — Baseline (2017 + 360 + emergency) | $452,080.27 | |
| Construction — Alternate (PAA/Neratoff + 360 + emergency) | $419,974.97 |
Constant elements across scenarios: Emergency + 360 = $140,080.27 (non‑duplicative; health/safety work + work already performed).
2) Emergency Self‑Help Detail (QM)¶
- Labor (QM): $17,000.00 (1,700 sq ft × $10/sq ft). Industry range $8–$12/sq ft; contemporaneous phone consult with Scott Lieberman (ServiceMaster) memorialized in Excel (CPLR 4518 business records).
- Materials: $1,080.27 via 18 purchases (Oct 15–Dec 12, 2019):
- CSV export (14) $722.15 → Home Depot $178.32, Tri‑State Lumber $519.12, 4 Season Paint $24.71.
- Bank‑ledger checkcard (4) $358.12 → Home Depot $100.00, $157.66, $77.27, $23.19.
- Tiering: Tier 1 (CSV+ledger scans; receipts where preserved) · Tier 2 (Lieberman notes; industry corroboration) · Tier 3 (timeline & purchase‑pattern).
Full body (legal foundation, timeline, transaction‑by‑transaction, exhibits plan): See Tab 101.7A.
3) Comparative Scenarios (construction totals with emergency)¶
| Scenario | Emergency | Rainbow | 360 | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baseline (claim anchor) | $18,080.27 | $312,000.00 | $122,000.00 | $452,080.27 |
| Alternate (reference) | $18,080.27 | $279,894.70 | $122,000.00 | $419,974.97 |
Per‑sq‑ft (1,700 sq ft): Baseline $265.34/sq ft; Alternate $247.04/sq ft. Emergency $10.63/sq ft (labor $10.00, materials $0.64).
4) De‑Duplication Guardrails¶
- Construction vs. contents: Emergency/contractor items are structural/remediation and do not appear in Tabs 101.1–101.6 (contents).
- Appliances: Items in 101.3 were outside Rainbow’s scope → keeps categories clean.
- Cross‑tabs: No overlap with Alt Housing (Tab 102/103), Transportation (Tab 103), Business Income (Tab 104), or Forced Liquidation (Tab 106).
5) Evidence Links (drop your files)¶
- Bank CSV: Karuna_Flood_Search_2019.csv → (attach/link)
- Bank ledger scans (checkcard 4 txns): (attach/link)
- Excel note (ServiceMaster consult, Oct 2019): (attach/link)
- Rainbow 2017 PDF: (attach/link)
- Rainbow PAA/Neratoff PDF: (attach/link)
- 360 Restoration PDF: (attach/link)
- Pre‑flood photos / floor plan / Loft Law records: (attach/link)
6) Routing & Interest¶
- Interest (9% simple, CPLR 5001–5004): compute per item in Tab 002.
- Discovery use: Use Tab 101.7A for affidavit requests, exhibit lists, and production packets.
ROUTING: All Calculations in Tab 002¶
All mathematical calculations are performed in Blue Tab 002 — G21 Base Damages — Mathematical Verification (REPL Appendix):
- This page's construction/emergency totals feed into Tab 002
- Interest: 9% simple per CPLR 5001–5004
- Date anchors: Per Blue Tab 002 §3.2 (category-specific)
¶
END — Blue Tab 101.7 — Construction & Emergency Mitigation Evidence v1.3