Skip to content

Red Tab 102.10 — David Shinn (Award-Winning Master Audio Engineer and Custom Studio Builder) — Pre-Flood Specialist Consultation and Multi-Stage Build Witness

GUARDRAIL: RED — FREEMAN STREET DAMAGES

Freeman Street opportunity-loss damages only. No G21 base damages, no enterprise multipliers.

Navigation: ← Return to Tab 102 (Grammy Opportunity)

LAYER 0: METADATA & SCOPE

Purpose. Evidence‑only nested page for the Grammy Opportunity category (Tab 102 — 15% allocation). Documents David Shinn (award‑winning master audio engineer, sound designer, Foley artist, and custom studio builder; Audio Systems Technical Advisor per institutional roster) and his pre‑flood specialist consultation engagement with Freeman Street — covering acoustic isolation, recording‑studio construction methods and materials, and broader audio‑engineering advisory — sustained as a multi‑stage build witness from September 2013 onward through present. No local calculations. All dollars and policy multipliers are centralized in Tab 001 and verified in Tab 002.

Platform identity. Freeman Street Studios is a creator‑economy production platform and private event venue; this page relies on the canonical October 2019 commissioning snapshot and absolute dates used section‑wide.

Series placement note. Tab 102 is treated as a professional peer‑validator network rather than strictly Grammy‑tier. Tab 102.10 anchors the technical specialist (Audie‑tier audio engineering) sub‑lane within that network, parallel to Tab 102.1 (Krasno) and Tab 102.2 (Elevado) on the September 24, 2013 three‑validator first‑meeting convergence day at the studio. Tab 102.10 sits alongside Tab 102.9 (Rick St. Hilaire) as a 102‑series extension that broadens the validator architecture without breaking the Grammy‑tier framing of 102.1–102.5.

Context & cross‑links. This validator page is people‑first for the Grammy lane and cross‑references: Tab 102.1 (Krasno) and Tab 102.2 (Elevado) as same‑day first‑meeting peers; Tab 101.3 §D (pre‑flood technical install foundation cluster) for the Bevin Robinson low‑voltage audio install team and Tim Gregoire SDI backbone install supervision context; Tab 101.9 (Expert Witness Coordination Framework) for affidavit‑availability framing; and Tab 201 (Infrastructure / System 6) for SDI backbone install context.

Evidence‑only notice. Category and nested pages in Red display weight only and route all mathematics to Tab 001 (framework) with Tab 002 (REPL) verification.

LAYER 1: CALCULATION REFERENCE

CALCULATION REFERENCE
=====================
Parent Tab: Tab 102 (Grammy — 15% Allocation)
All Financial Calculations: Tab 001 (Framework) & Tab 002 (REPL)
This Page: Evidence repository only — no local calculations

Scenario Totals (Freeman-only): See Tab 001 — $25.0M / $100.0M / $200.0M
Verification: See Tab 002 — REPL Appendix (policy multipliers applied once)

(All category weights and policy multipliers are fixed in Tab 001; Tab 002 reproduces and verifies the totals. No dollars appear on this nested page.)

LAYER 2: EVIDENCE FRAMEWORK

A. Role & Credentials (technical specialist validator)

  • David Shinn — award‑winning master audio engineer, sound designer, Foley artist, and custom studio builder; nine Audie Award nominations with two wins; additional recognition from The Communicator Awards, Earphone Awards, and The International Radio Festival. Technical Director, National Audio Theatre Festivals. Co‑founder and co‑owner, Radio Waves Studios (award‑winning full‑service production/post‑production studio for film, TV, audiobooks, podcasts, and web content).
  • Audio Systems Technical Advisor to the Freeman Street facility per the institutional roster (Notion Team page, contemporaneous documentary record).
  • Contact anchors (independent of corporate/institutional channels): audiodude13@gmail.com (Gmail; "audiodude" handle aligns with the Audio Systems Technical Advisor role); phone (516) 885‑8360 (516 area code = Nassau County, NY / Long Island).
  • This validator establishes technical‑specialist tier acoustic‑engineering consultation demand for the Grammy lane, distinct from the operator/producer validation tier captured at Tab 102.1 and Tab 102.2 and distinct from corporate/label validations captured under Tab 101.

B. Documentary Initiation (September–October 2013)

Source document compilation: EX‑SHINN‑2013‑PDF — Shinn Email Chain (Sep 25 + Oct 3, 2013). Also indexed in §G below.

  • September 24, 2013 — first in‑person meeting at the studio. Shinn first meets Christian on the same day Eric Krasno (Tab 102.1) and Russell Elevado (Tab 102.2) first meet Christian at the studio — the three‑validator first‑meeting convergence day for the Freeman Street pre‑flood validator network. First‑meeting anchored by reciprocal email statements (Christian: "It was great to meet you the other day"; Shinn: "A pleasure to meet you as well").
  • September 25, 2013 (morning) — Christian → Shinn (EX‑SHINN‑2013‑01): Supply‑house follow‑up request; phone‑number capture correction. Establishes immediate post‑meeting business‑development continuation.
  • September 25, 2013, 5:11 PM — Shinn → Christian (EX‑SHINN‑2013‑02): Trademark Soundproofing (Monsey, NY) identification; three floor‑isolation product recommendations (Peacemaker anti‑vibration material; Duracoustic; Iso‑Step underlayment); MLV (Mass‑Loaded Vinyl) and Green Glue specification context; verified phone (516) 885‑8360.
  • October 2, 2013 — second Christian–Shinn conversation (anchored by Email C "from our conversation yesterday"; likely phone given the multi‑link follow‑up format the next day).
  • October 3, 2013, 12:17 PM — Shinn → Christian (EX‑SHINN‑2013‑03): Four additional product/supplier specifications — recording‑studio doors (soundproofwindows.com); ultraquiet ceiling system (Kinetics Noise); QWood acoustic panel datasheet; soundproof nailed‑down wood floor system.
  • October 3, 2013, 3:27 PM — Shinn → Christian (EX‑SHINN‑2013‑04): Gasket‑tape follow‑up (same Trademark Soundproofing supplier from EX‑SHINN‑2013‑02).
  • Initial engagement was pure consultation / informal advisory — not a paid engagement. Documentary force flows from contemporaneous expert‑specification content, not contractual instruments.

C. October 2019 Commissioning Snapshot (canonical)

  • George Augspurger mains — installed in control room wall system
  • 48‑channel API Legacy Plus — installed, being customized
  • Studer A800 24‑track — aligned
  • All audio/video/data cabling — terminated/tested
  • Museum‑grade acoustic treatment — complete
  • Vintage microphone collection — secure storage at Freeman
  • Pro Tools system and Focal Twin6 Be 5.1 — at G21, later damaged (Blue)
  • Baldwin SF‑10 7.5′ grand piano — commercial storage
  • Facility weeks from full operation when the G21 flood (Oct 13, 2019) forced emergency residential use.

D. Multi‑Stage Build Witness Arc (September 2013 → Present)

Shinn's engagement with Freeman Street spans approximately thirteen years as of the current binder cycle, sustained at consultation/advisory tier across the full build, flood‑interruption, and continuation arc. Shinn did not directly perform install work; his role across all stages is consultation, site visits, and expert specification advisory on acoustic isolation and recording‑studio construction methods and materials.

Stage Period Engagement profile
D.1 Initial consultation Sep 2013 → late 2013 First‑meeting + four‑email specification arc (EX‑SHINN‑2013‑01 through 04); soundproofing supplier identification; floor‑isolation and door/ceiling/panel system specifications.
D.2 Sustained pre‑flood phase 2014 → Oct 2019 Consistent check‑ins that became more frequent. No formal schedule. Consultation and periodic site visits across the buildout phase. Shinn did not participate in the 2015–2019 install work directly (API Legacy Plus install, Augspurger main monitors install, SDI backbone install, museum‑grade acoustic treatment, Atmos 7.1.4 planning); his role remained consultation and site visits on acoustic isolation and construction methods/materials.
D.3 Post‑flood continuation Oct 13, 2019 → present Consistent engagement throughout the years; no formal schedule. Maintained advisory presence across the displacement and continuation period.
D.4 Current advisor status 2026 Active roster status — ongoing live engagement. Listed on the Audio Systems Technical Advisors roster as an active advisor (not roster‑archive status).

Documentary trail beyond the four 2013 emails: [HOLD — additional emails, contracts, photos, or technical specifications authored by Shinn across stages D.2–D.4 to be captured at Christian‑direct Layer 2 expansion. Tab 102.10 v1.0 documentary force rests on the EX‑SHINN‑2013‑01 through 04 chain + Notion Team page institutional roster status + Christian‑direct continuation testimony; supplementary documentary evidence upgrades to v1.1.]

Sep 2013 professional positioning anchors: [HOLD — first‑meeting professional positioning (independent consultant vs. Radio Waves Studios affiliation vs. National Audio Theatre Festivals affiliation timing) and the specific connector who brought Shinn and Christian together on September 24, 2013 to be captured at Christian‑direct Layer 2 expansion to v1.1.]

E. Peer & Corporate Bridges (Where this fits)

  • Three‑validator first‑meeting convergence: September 24, 2013 anchors Tab 102.10 architecturally parallel to Tab 102.1 (Eric Krasno) and Tab 102.2 (Russell Elevado) — three independent professional validators first‑meeting Christian at the studio on the same day, all generating contemporaneous documentary trails within nine days. Tighter pre‑flood validator convergence than any other single moment in the Freeman Street record.
  • Pre‑flood technical install foundation cluster (Tab 101.3 §D): Shinn's acoustic‑isolation specification work is the expert‑specialist layer that the low‑voltage audio install (Bevin Robinson, November 2012 onward) and SDI backbone install (Tim Gregoire, supervision) build upon. Specification → install relationship is operationally upstream from Tab 101.3 §D's install‑team focus.
  • Expert witness coordination framework (Tab 101.9): Shinn's affidavit availability is scoped within the Tab 101.9 affidavit‑capture workflow; specific affidavit scope and timing addressed at Layer 3 below.
  • Peer overlap with other Audio Systems Technical Advisors: [HOLD — collaboration or coordination with other Notion roster Audio Systems Technical Advisors (Bevin Robinson, Robert Miller, Rick St. Hilaire, Kirk Yano, Andrew Hollis, Eric Krasno) on the Freeman Street project to be captured at Christian‑direct Layer 2 expansion to v1.1.]

F. Resource Diversion (verbatim)

While commitments were in place, the G21 flood (Oct 13, 2019) forced emergency residential use of Freeman Street and diverted resources:

  • Legal battles re: G21 habitability – 100+ hours
  • Environmental inspector coordination – 50+ hours
  • Contractor remediation assessments – 75+ hours
  • Alternative housing search (toxic unit offered) – 40+ hours
  • Health management from mold exposure – 30+ hours
  • Insurance claim administration – 60+ hours

Total diverted from business development: 355+ hours (≈ 9+ weeks FTE)

(Diversion narrative anchored in Section Parent; applied consistently across Red.)

G. Artifacts Index

  • EX‑SHINN‑2013‑01 — Christian → Shinn, September 25, 2013 (morning); supply‑house follow‑up + phone‑number correction; first‑meeting reciprocal acknowledgment
  • EX‑SHINN‑2013‑02 — Shinn → Christian, September 25, 2013, 5:11 PM; Trademark Soundproofing identification + three floor isolation product specifications + verified phone number
  • EX‑SHINN‑2013‑03 — Shinn → Christian, October 3, 2013, 12:17 PM; four additional product/supplier specifications (doors / ultraquiet ceiling / QWood panel / nailed‑down soundproof wood floor)
  • EX‑SHINN‑2013‑04 — Shinn → Christian, October 3, 2013, 3:27 PM; gasket‑tape follow‑up specification
  • EX‑SHINN‑2013‑PDF — Shinn Email Chain (September 25 + October 3, 2013) — PDF compilation reference for EX‑SHINN‑2013‑01 through EX‑SHINN‑2013‑04; display/viewing instrument. Native .eml exhibit‑grade capture with SHA‑256 hashing pending per §5 Implementation Roadmap step 1 (Tab 103.1 §5.1 custody standards). View PDF →
  • EX‑SHINN‑NOTION‑01 — Notion Team / Audio Systems Technical Advisors roster page — David Shinn entry (contemporaneous institutional documentary instrument)
  • EX‑SHINN‑AFF‑01 — Declaration (Shinn) re: September 2013 first engagement; multi‑stage build witness; pre‑flood operational readiness; post‑flood continuation; current advisor status; technical assessment of facility capability [scope and timing per Layer 3 below]
  • Cross‑refs: Tab 102 (parent); Tab 102.1 (Krasno — Sep 24, 2013 convergence peer); Tab 102.2 (Elevado — Sep 24, 2013 convergence peer); Tab 101.3 §D (Bevin Robinson / Tim Gregoire technical install foundation); Tab 101.9 (Expert Witness Coordination Framework); Tab 201 (System 6 / SDI backbone); EX‑DOLBY‑01 (Sept 2024) / EX‑UMG‑25 (Sept 2025).
  • Custody status: Native .eml capture with SHA‑256 hashing pending per Tab 103.1 §5.1 custody standards (parallel workstream; not gating v1.0; upgrades to exhibit‑grade per Tab 103.1 standards).

LAYER 3: WITNESS COORDINATION

Primary witness — David Shinn (master audio engineer; custom studio builder; acoustic isolation specialist; Audio Systems Technical Advisor).

Expected testimony: (i) September 2013 first engagement and the specification content of the September 25 + October 3, 2013 documentary record; (ii) multi‑stage build witness arc from September 2013 onward through present, sustained at consultation/advisory tier across pre‑flood buildout, flood‑interruption, and continuation phases; (iii) pre‑flood operational readiness assessment based on multi‑year specification and site‑visit observation; (iv) post‑flood continuation engagement and current active advisor status; (v) technical assessment of facility capability from the acoustic‑isolation and studio‑construction perspective; (vi) confirmation that all damages math is centralized in Tab 001/002.

Affidavit availability: Shinn has affirmed willingness to provide an affidavit covering the engagement scope above. Affidavit‑capture workflow scoped within the Tab 101.9 framework; capture timing per Christian‑direct planning post‑Tab 102.10 lock.

Role characterization (working): Acoustic Isolation Specialist and Recording‑Studio Construction Consultant; Multi‑Stage Build Witness (September 2013 → Present).

Corroborating witnesses (context only):

  • Eric Krasno (Grammy‑winning artist/producer) — base‑studio operator commitment + September 24, 2013 first‑meeting convergence peer (see Tab 102.1).
  • Russell Elevado (multi‑Grammy mix engineer) — analog‑workflow operator validation + September 24, 2013 first‑meeting convergence peer (see Tab 102.2).
  • Bevin Robinson — low‑voltage audio install team (November 2012 onward); pre‑flood technical install foundation peer (see Tab 101.3 §D).
  • Tim Gregoire — SDI backbone install supervision; pre‑flood technical install foundation peer (see Tab 201 System 6).
  • Kirk Yano (Sony) — Grammy‑peer audio engineer / fellow Audio Systems Technical Advisor (see Tab 101.5 / Tab 102.3).
  • Contemporary Mission Corp. v. Famous Music Corp., 557 F.2d 918 (2d Cir. 1977) - Substantial probability standard.
  • Schonfeld v. Hilliard, 218 F.3d 164 (2d Cir. 2000) - Lost profits from prevented business relationships.
  • Kenford Co. v. County of Erie, 67 N.Y.2d 257 (1986) - Reasonable certainty for consequential damages.

Application. Shinn's engagement profile supplies four convergent evidentiary inputs for the Grammy lane's substantial‑probability and reasonable‑certainty showings, without any local dollar calculations on this page:

  1. Pre‑flood engagement timing. The September 2013 first‑meeting date — anchored by contemporaneous email correspondence (EX‑SHINN‑2013‑01 through 04) — places Shinn's engagement six years prior to the October 13, 2019 flood and within the third year of the sixteen‑year facility commitment arc. Engagement substantially predates any litigation or insurance‑driven motivation.
  2. Technical‑specialist tier expert content. The four 2013 emails contain engineering‑specification‑level acoustic‑isolation guidance (MLV density specification, Green Glue damping compound application, floor isolation underlayment systems, recording‑studio door specification, ceiling‑isolation systems, acoustic wall panel specification, gasket‑tape application). This is documentary‑grade expert work product, not general advisory communication.
  3. Multi‑stage build witness continuity. Christian‑direct testimony establishes Shinn's continuous consultation engagement from September 2013 through present (approximately thirteen years), spanning the pre‑flood buildout, the October 13, 2019 flood interruption, and the post‑flood continuation period. The Notion Team page Audio Systems Technical Advisors roster — a contemporaneous institutional documentary instrument — confirms current active advisor status as of 2026. This continuity profile addresses the preexisting‑venture continuation question directly with established track‑record evidence.
  4. September 24, 2013 three‑validator first‑meeting convergence. Three independent professional validators — Grammy‑winning artist/producer (Krasno, Tab 102.1), multi‑Grammy mix engineer (Elevado, Tab 102.2), and award‑winning master audio engineer / custom studio builder (Shinn, Tab 102.10) — first‑meeting Christian at the studio on the same day, each generating contemporaneous documentary trails within nine days. The convergence is independent of any single validator's subsequent recollection because three separate documentary records corroborate the same first‑meeting day. Tighter pre‑flood validator convergence than any other single moment in the Freeman Street pre‑flood record.

Taken together, these inputs establish substantial probability and reasonable certainty for the Grammy lane consistent with Contemporary Mission, Schonfeld, and Kenford, with all damages math confined to Tab 001/002.

LAYER 5: IMPLEMENTATION ROADMAP

  1. Native .eml capture (parallel workstream). Capture EX‑SHINN‑2013‑01 through EX‑SHINN‑2013‑04 in native .eml format from Christian's email archive with full headers (Received chain, Message‑ID, References, In‑Reply‑To). Compute SHA‑256 hash on capture; record in custody CSV per Tab 103.1 §5.1. Filename convention EX-SHINN-2013-0N_v1_YYYY-MM-DD.eml; foldering /Red_Vol06/Tab102.10/Exhibits/EX-SHINN-2013-0N/. Not gating Tab 102.10 v1.0; upgrades to exhibit‑grade.
  2. Affidavit capture (EX‑SHINN‑AFF‑01). Execute Shinn affidavit covering September 2013 first engagement; multi‑stage build witness arc; pre‑flood operational readiness assessment; post‑flood continuation engagement; current active advisor status; technical assessment of facility capability. Scope and timing per Christian‑direct planning; capture window per Tab 101.9 expert‑witness coordination workflow.
  3. Layer 2 expansion to v1.1. Capture: (a) September 2013 professional positioning anchors (independent consultant vs. Radio Waves Studios affiliation vs. National Audio Theatre Festivals affiliation timing); (b) connector who facilitated the September 24, 2013 first meeting; (c) collaboration/coordination with other Audio Systems Technical Advisors on the Freeman Street project; (d) supplementary documentary trail (additional emails, contracts, invoices, photos, technical specifications) across stages D.2–D.4.
  4. Pin‑cite map. Create a short index linking Shinn statements to the canonical October 2019 facts, the September 25 + October 3, 2013 documentary record, and the post‑2019 validation events. No dollars.
  5. Witness sequencing. Present this page with Tab 102.1 (Krasno) and Tab 102.2 (Elevado) to establish the September 24, 2013 three‑validator first‑meeting convergence; with Tab 101.3 §D (Bevin Robinson / Tim Gregoire) to establish the pre‑flood technical install foundation context; and route all dollars to Tab 001/002.
  6. Trial narrative (illustrative). Three‑validator first‑meeting day (September 24, 2013) → Documentary specification record (September 25 + October 3, 2013) → Multi‑stage build witness arc (2013 → present) → Active advisor status (2026) → Affidavit testimony (EX‑SHINN‑AFF‑01) → Damages math in Tab 001/002 only.

END — Red Tab 102.10 — David Shinn (Award-Winning Master Audio Engineer and Custom Studio Builder) — Pre-Flood Specialist Consultation and Multi-Stage Build Witness v1.0.3